As Chimp Research is Phased Out, Will Other Animal Research Decline?
Research

Justin Goodman

, 07/09/2013

As Chimp Research is Phased Out, Will Other Animal Research Decline?

(Research) Permanent link

The institution of animal experimentation is a house of cards, and a stiff wind is blowing at last. 

At a meeting last month about federal funding for science, former National Institutes of Health director  Elias Zerhouni admitted that experimenting on animals has been a boondoggle. “We have moved away from studying human disease in humans,” he said. ”We all drank the Kool-Aid on that one, me included.”

“The problem is that it hasn’t worked, and it’s time we stopped dancing around the problem.” he continued. We need to refocus and adapt new methodologies for use in humans to understand disease biology in humans.”

Zerhouni’s comments are timely. Earlier this year, a high-profile study found that sophisticated tests using human cells accurately predict what happens to people when they’re burned and suffer infections, but that the standard method of burning mice’s skin off in experiments does not. Scientists now understand why all 150 drugs developed using these animals didn’t work in human patients. Current NIH Director Dr. Francis Collins called the finding, "a heartbreaking loss of decades of research and billions of dollars."  Similar to Zerhouni’s recent sentiments, the study's lead author told the New York Times, "[Researchers] are so ingrained in trying to cure mice that they forget we are trying to cure humans."

This extrapolation problem exists with the species most biologically similar to humans as well. A landmark 2011 study by the Institute of Medicine found that “most current biomedical research use of chimpanzees is unnecessary.” A subsequent NIH report agreed and even concluded that “research involving chimpanzees has rarely accelerated new discoveries or the advancement of human health for infectious diseases.”  Yet, until very recently, NIH was spending millions on things like strapping down chimpanzees to have thousands of mosquitoes feed on their bare skin and separating baby chimpanzees from their mothers, locking them alone in cages, and forcing liquid filtered from human stool down their throats to intentionally sicken them with stomach viruses.  Thankfully, the NIH announced last month that it will retire hundreds of chimpanzees to sanctuaries and cut funding for most invasive experiments on them.       

Like the IOM’s chimpanzee study, and a 2007 National Academy of Sciences report that called for a drastic shift away from animal use for chemical toxicity testing, comprehensive reviews of all NIH-funded experiments on monkeys, mice, and every other nonhuman species are sorely needed. It is likely that they would reveal the same kind of waste of money and lives on experiments that have not helped humans in the past and may be unnecessary in the future.

The Food and Drug Administration has reported that 9 out of 10 drugs that are safe and effective in animals either don’t work in humans or cause harm. This spring, human trials of an experimental HIV vaccine – that were expanded based on experiments in monkeys – were halted when it was discovered that the vaccine did not prevent HIV infection or reduce viral load in those already infected. Indeed, all of the nearly 90 preventive HIV vaccines that made it to human clinical trials have failed despite working in experiments on monkeys. Harvard’s decision to shutter its embattled New England Primate Research Center, where many HIV studies on primates were being conducted, is a sign that such a prestigious institution doesn’t see experiments on primates as the future of science. 

Despite all of this, the NIH continues to devote roughly half of its $30 billion budget to projects that involve experiments with animals, including those that infect monkeys with debilitating HIV-like illnesses, induce heart attacks in dogs forced to run on treadmills, mutilate rats’ penises in erectile dysfunction experiments, and other ethically and scientifically questionable studies.

The public has been willing to support experiments on animals only because it has not understood the cruelty involved and has accepted the argument that harming animals was crucial to advancing science.  But many now think otherwise. Public opinion polls show that more Americans than ever find “medical testing on animals” to be “morally wrong” and the number is growing. These people are demanding accountability and effecting change in science policy and practice. The scientific reviews that ultimately led to the severe curtailment of experiments on chimpanzees were only undertaken because of moral outrage that the U.S. is the last country in the industrialized world that still engages in the practice.

The scientific community needs to pull its proverbial head out of the sand and acknowledge that poisoning, crippling, and infecting other animals in experiments isn’t a sound way to improve human health. Everyone wins if, as Dr. Zerhouni advises, researchers invest their time, money, and brainpower into further developing, refining and utilizing 21st century non-animal research methods that are actually relevant to humans.   

Justin Goodman is the director of the laboratory investigations department at People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals (PETA). He is also an adjunct instructor of sociology at Marymount University and serves on the leadership council of the American Sociological Association’s Animals and Society section. 

Posted by Susan Gilbert at 07/09/2013 05:27:54 PM | 


Comments
The so-called "war" on cancer has remained unchanged for six decades. The same three treatments available in 1950 - radiation, chemo and surgery - are the same today in 2013. Yet animal models are still being touted as the breakthrough in-waiting. It's nonsense. Testing on animals does. not. work. Yet we cling to this cruel practice instead of venturing into new, innovative models and those truly with the potential for a breakthrough. What's that saying, "doing the same thing over and over and expecting a different result is the definition of insanity." Conducting experiments on animals is insanity.
Posted by: stkittchick@hotmail.com ( Email ) at 7/10/2013 11:59 AM


Experimenting on animals--any animals--only sets humanity back. We fail to be ethical and we fail to use scientifically sound research methods. Both animals and people pay the price for this medical folly. We must start using progressive, effective, and humane research methods.
Posted by: hmoore123@comcast.net ( Email ) at 7/10/2013 4:20 PM


When group fence over the use of animals in search, also called vivisection, there are those who argue the animals and those who reason the investigate.
Posted by: smkn4bengkulu@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 6/3/2014 12:05 AM


Experimenting on animals--any animals--is an awful did that I'm strongly against it. What would happen if we would experiment on humans? We should protest all clinical trials.
Posted by: eronenisme@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 9/2/2014 5:10 PM


Not so bad...
Thanks to author.
Posted by: smartmil888@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 9/8/2014 3:52 PM


Experimenting on animals--any animals--is an awful did that I'm strongly against it. What would happen if we would experiment on humans? We should protest all clinical trials.
Posted by: davidjohn051@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 9/11/2014 1:23 AM


The truth is that it's difficult to acquire folks that are generally prescribed Oxycodone with regard to legitimate discomfort, becoming hooked. They're able to turn into physically influenced by Oxycodone but as the anguish gets managed, the actual measure could be brought down. The reality that remedies will probably be at the same time employed in addition to the Oxycodone help focus along with reinforce exactly why they are taking the idea. Through the time to come your struggle to reduce the actual devastating aftereffect of the anguish can include lack of feeling hindrances, heat and cold treatment options, bodily as well as work therapy, nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory medicines, electrical excitement, psychophysiological feedback, mao inhibitors, psychiatric therapy, alternative healthcare, behavior customization, as well as other therapies. Every single treatments will include visits, checks, remedy, reevaluations and so on.
Posted by: eronenisme@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 10/12/2014 6:14 AM


Egypt is regarded as one of several most ancient culture on the planet. Old Egyptian people revealed their excellence in numerous areas such as the area of medicine. Inside their most ancient therapeutic textbooks, that they defined bowel problems treatment also. Aloe Foreign exchange is referred to as an excellent irregularity treatment that will capabilities properly as a organic organic for the gastrointestinal system. It really is widely common due to its natural power to prevent -inflammatory digestive problems.
Posted by: janice.merkoward@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 10/22/2014 12:24 PM


In the past healthy eating may possibly mean "bland, boring and boring" however nowadays, with all the current choices we have accessible, it genuinely may be both "delicious and enjoyable". It is crucial that many of us adopt an optimistic attitude to your foodstuff and make sure that food in fact is certainly one of life's delights.
Posted by: janice.merkoward@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 11/4/2014 12:12 PM


Another healthy switch to take into account is actually reducing snack foods and soft drink out of your diet regime. Rather than soft drink, sip trunks about flavoured h2o, refreshing fruit juice, or perhaps green tea. Rather than deciding on cream-filled desserts, choose vegetables or perhaps unbuttered snacks.
Posted by: oyahaloms@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 11/9/2014 6:51 AM


Purchasing organic foodstuff can be relatively high-priced. In the event you quit acquiring the food which are not wholesome, for example soda pops, when compared with you may get back a portion of your respective monthly budget that will be applied to better food items. Reduce costs involving organically grown meals by collecting large quantities wherever it feels right through getting the products total as an alternative to pre-cut. For example, you'll pay a lot less for two main as well as 3 red peppers if you purchase all of them if they're complete as opposed to purchasing a package which might be pre-cut.
Posted by: oyahaloms@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 11/9/2014 6:51 AM


Along with workout, you allow the body to deal with items involving strain as well as speed up exercise. It will help the body produce protective hormones faster. As well as celebrate your head inform, it is possible to react to everyday situations and make healthful judgements.
Posted by: orkooper@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 11/17/2014 5:26 PM


Workout ought to be done following a conditioning examination. You would not would like you to ultimately go crazy. You could possibly wind up fatigued. It is important that an individual confer with your physician or trainer prior to starting any kind of health and fitness programs.
Posted by: orkooper@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 11/17/2014 5:26 PM


The first thing is to remain productive there is no need to go away and operate regarding mile after mile to become and grow balanced. All you have to carry out is walk throughout the town; move at the start of the morning hours with a school observe, or possibly a car park that has a going for walks way. Stroll with this in mind more than once a week and remain productive. This really is good for you.
Posted by: boni.experius@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 11/25/2014 2:30 PM


However that does not mean you have to find heavier, you can beat the percentages and conquer facts by existing a structured as well as balanced existence. If you're viewing a few a long time involving TV, or sitting down and shelling out five several hours per day on your computer, you need to decrease just a little. Acquire an hour or so out as well as stroll 3 mls. If you're pigging out unhealthy foods next take into account a few wholesome snack foods.
Posted by: amyahlom@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 11/29/2014 7:34 AM


That is fairly generally whenever you lose thick uterine liner along with the proper blood circulation inside of via your vaginal canal every 21-thirty days approximately. The actual never-ending cycle is unique throughout everyone. Several women may get their particular periods much more detailed a part as opposed to runners. This can be the same with how much time the actual durations previous
Posted by: boni.experius@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 11/29/2014 7:50 PM


However, when you jump right within you ought to understand that extraordinary changes are usually damaging on the process. You do not want for you to force on your own excessive initially more than you can handle along with turn out falling the thought completely. For this reason it is usually advised that you can make little, progressive modifications in your everyday life-style routines.
Posted by: orkooper@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 12/1/2014 4:02 AM