Controversy in the Hastings Center Report: Responding to an Article on Obesity
Media
Gregory E. Kaebnick, 01/25/2013

Controversy in the Hastings Center Report: Responding to an Article on Obesity

(Media) Permanent link

Nearly everyone agrees that obesity is a significant public health problem in the United States, and nearly everyone agrees that the public health responses to it so far have been disappointing.  So what should be done about it? In the January-February issue of the Hastings Center Report, an article by Hastings Center co-founder, senior scholar, and president emeritus Daniel Callahan urges more government regulation, business initiatives, a focus on childhood prevention, and stepping up social pressure to discourage people from becoming obese.  Callahan argues that social pressure was successfully employed to reduce the incidence of smoking in the United States.

The article’s focus on social pressure is extremely controversial, as responses from the media, readers, other bioethicists, other Hastings scholars, and the general public is making abundantly clear. (These blog posts at The Atlantic and The Huffington Post are representative.) Respondents have raised a number of objections to this part of Callahan’s argument: that it gets the facts about stigmatization wrong, that the analogy to smoking mischaracterizes what was effective about smoking prevention efforts, and that it is demeaning to people who are overweight (and already agonizing about it). In addition, some who have seen reports about the article are concerned that Callahan’s position may increase school bullying.

The article is actually one of several very controversial pieces that have appeared in the Report in recent years. Others include articles on the Western media coverage of female genital cutting and on physician involvement in executions and torture. And scores of articles, essays, and other commentary in the Report have staked out positions that, though less controversial than the positions above, are still deeply objectionable to at least some readers.

The editorial decision whether to publish these pieces is often difficult, even agonizing. Accepting an article for publication may look like accepting the article’s position, but in fact, the question we try to answer is not whether we agree with the piece. The Report and the Center exist to foster free debate on important and very difficult questions, and they therefore try to avoid taking positions themselves. Those of us who edit the Report sometimes agree with what eventually appears in the Report, and sometimes disagree. (And others at The Hastings Center may agree or disagree with the Report’s decisions about publication.)

Publishing an article certainly reflects a decision that the article makes a useful contribution of some sort to the societal discussions it addresses. What counts as a “useful contribution” is complicated, though. One great way of contributing usefully to a debate is to point out the right answer to it, but even a position that is roundly rejected may be said to move a debate forward—by effectively articulating a widely held position, for example, clarifying a distinction, or showing the implications of an analogy. A widely rejected piece can also be useful by stimulating insights from readers who might then become authors themselves.

Neither do we want to go to the other extreme, of course, and stir up controversy for controversy’s sake. It is ongoing productive exchange that we seek, not just authors with whom we agree and not just authors who will goad us or our readers.

In that spirit, we invite responses to Callahan’s article, both on Bioethics Forum and in the Hastings Center Report. The responses should be thoughtful, but they may certainly disagree with the positions Callahan tries to develop, and they may disagree very strongly. We cannot promise to publish everything sent us, but we are interested in seeing your views.  We aim to use this occasion to generate wide-ranging ideas about how best to address the obesity epidemic. Those interested in writing commentaries are encouraged to contact us at editorial@thehastingscenter.org.

Gregory E. Kaebnick is the editor of the Hastings Center Report and editorial director of The Hastings Center.

Posted by Susan Gilbert at 01/25/2013 12:08:46 PM | 


Comments
Yes, it is true that obesity is considered as a significant public health problem that the public health committee must solved immediately. There are hundreds of obese people and they continue to increase at an alarming speed if not solved. Although they'll be able to reinforce serving healthier food at school cafeteria, what they eat outside of school is their choice. How can it be solved?
Posted by: ladyfiona143@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 1/13/2014 7:52 AM


However if you simply try to eat such as rubbish it's gonna think on your entire body and overall wellbeing, both mentally and physically, although you may work out vigorously everyday. Furthermore? To eat more healthy, you'll feel better about your self, excess fat may minimize for that greater. You will are living healthier as well as direct an even more satisfying living.
Posted by: amyahlom@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 12/8/2014 4:58 PM


You've got a increased potential for getting obese or overweight should you overlook eating healthily behavior. As well as furthermore become more prone to depressive disorders and also other life-threatening conditions for example most cancers as well as center failure. Sufficient top reasons to are living healthier?
Posted by: amyahlom@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 12/8/2014 4:58 PM


Have a number of foods: It really is proper along with required to integrate not simply a good amount of fruits and vegetables but additionally to feature grain and healthy proteins. Vegatables and fruits are an essential way to obtain all-natural anti-oxidants that are nearly impossible to find in other places. And by not including fruits and vegetables to their everyday eating plans, most of the people overlook the primary vitamins and minerals needed for a proper dwelling. Ensure you have 3-5 areas of fruits and vegetables every day.
Posted by: amyahlom@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 12/8/2014 4:59 PM


Consume sufficient calorie consumption: Several duplicates regarding studies has demonstrated that the inexperienced must eat about A couple of,1000 calorie consumption per day. As well as the much more the way of life an individual participate depending on your real age, weight and height, the harder it really is expected your calories should increase.
Posted by: amyahlom@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 12/8/2014 4:59 PM


Of course, I have mentioned in which just before, but sleep is a very important things when you find yourself establishing the world unstoppable, and your supporters are usually yelling at you for additional.
Posted by: alex.yahaloms@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 12/12/2014 8:16 AM


Currently, I am not discounting the contests involving exercising and also staying on a diet. I am aware this is a lot easier for some people and much more a hardship on other folks. On the other hand have seen identified folks drop 30 pounds and some have been significantly less committed struggled to shed 10 pounds inside the same time period. This is the energy this kind of solution tool.

Currently, I am not discounting the contests involving exercising and also staying on a diet. I am aware this is a lot easier for some people and much more a hardship on other folks. On the other hand have seen identified folks drop 30 pounds and some have been significantly less committed struggled to shed 10 pounds inside the same time period. This is the energy this kind of solution tool.
Posted by: amyahlom@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 12/12/2014 3:29 PM


Nearly all undesirable habits tend to be acquired, but effortlessly stopped or even dismissed. It's rarely too soon to get started on dog obedience training, adding 20 to 30 units aside daily will proper these kind of behaviors. Pick a suitable occasion throughout the day in which the puppy is in relaxed condition along with open to find out.
Posted by: jenn.tenner2@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 1/6/2015 8:42 AM


I'm what a lot of people think about a fitness fanatic. With no our health, we now have nothing at all. That being said, nothing is more valuable next our very own wellness the health of other individuals. We review a few healthy routines in addition to nutritional vitamins along with healthful all-natural herbal supplements you are able to choose to use aid you in placing your goals.
Posted by: eronenisme@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 1/6/2015 5:24 PM


Healthy living and employ will help you stay a lengthy, pleased, along with healthy living. Many people might not know what exactly fitness is actually. Nicely I am going to explain.
Posted by: boni.experius@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 1/9/2015 1:20 PM


Existing healthful ways to prevent drugs, alcohol consumption, along with anything else that's harmful to one's body. Ingesting well is an additional way to are living wholesome. Working out regularly also grouped into the class of fitness.
Posted by: boni.experius@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 1/9/2015 1:21 PM


All of these items can result in a long existence. You will need to exercising typically not just in keep your pounds down nevertheless to improve your body at the same time. Exercising is able to keep a person cardiovascular powerful for several years by simply walking on a new treadmill a few times a week. This doesn't need to be anything hard or even exhausting to hold a person balanced.
Posted by: boni.experius@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 1/9/2015 1:21 PM


You are likely to wish to enter into this particular having a apparent head and a simple task that you're going to remain that which you begin. You'll
Posted by: eronenisme@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 1/14/2015 8:26 AM


Use low fat instead of extra fat greens dressing and also falls for greens along with salads. Yet again you are attempting to blend it and also include variety as to the and just how you consume.
Posted by: eronenisme@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 1/22/2015 6:00 AM


Your five trillion People in america every year. Thus, in case want to be healthful, you have to eat good food, handle unwanted weight, commence exercising preventing cigarette smoking.
Posted by: boni.experius@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 1/24/2015 6:42 AM


Most of these boost your skin layer and nourish the skin way over counter ointments full of chemicals.
Posted by: orkooper@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 1/26/2015 1:31 PM


Regarding outer care decide on natural skin care items along with hairdressing gas that is natural charm treatments and free of just about all germs and bacteria that you don't want with your entire body.
Posted by: orkooper@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 1/26/2015 1:31 PM


. Exactly what you need be drinking is filtered mineral water that is at a 70 degrees and never ice-cold normal water. Many people make this happen with no knowledge of that might in fact intervene with all the typical circumstances within the gastrointestinal system.
Posted by: eronenisme@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 1/31/2015 2:08 PM


Through taking out vegetables and fruit with their day-to-day diet programs, a lot of people overlook the primary nutrients needed for a healthy dwelling. Be sure to have got 3-5 areas of vegetables and fruit day-to-day.
Posted by: boni.experius@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 2/2/2015 8:28 AM


Any rise in workout have a beneficial impact on your present aerobic techniques. Plus your cardiovascular will cherish you because of it!
Posted by: eronenisme@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 2/2/2015 8:53 AM


Everything we consume affects our own bodies. Each of our daily eating routine make a decision standard condition individuals mind and body. To maintain our body salubrious and dynamic we've got to pinpoint the proper amount involving eating routine that our body requires. Certainly, balanced diet program offers you a wholesome existence. However what does that include?
Posted by: oyahaloms@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 2/2/2015 10:09 AM


. Yoga, aerobic exercises, kick-boxing, a new fairly fast stroll -- most of these measures are fantastic for the actual cardio-vascular system along with groups of muscles as well. And be sure you will get enough rest! Sleep deprivation is often a key reason exactly why people become unfocused along with to forget things. And, doing exercises frequently will allow you to sleep far better!
Posted by: ron.wingester@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 2/2/2015 12:00 PM


Gnawing of cigarette along with smoking cigarettes are two other major elements in which actively create nasty odours. Booze should be prevented.
Posted by: ron.wingester@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 2/4/2015 8:55 AM


Existing cook will need something too. Establishing a garden will give you will plenty of exercise. It is possible to conserve the yard whilst still being benefit from the physical exercise. Hanging out under the sun is also best for you total living.
Posted by: boni.experius@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 2/4/2015 6:21 PM


The issue with many shop acquired gluten-free breads is because are generally dry out where you can various structure through gluten that contains breads. By using a bakery device there is an capacity to try things out and also fine tune the particular breads made to meet your needs.
Posted by: amyahlom@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 2/6/2015 5:00 AM


The Art Of Fitness is based on the particular creative imagination of the individual. This way the person produces the best life style for him/herself, instead of a healthy way of life that fits someone else best yet is actually difficult that you can sustain.
Posted by: eronenisme@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 2/13/2015 1:47 PM