Deepwater Horizon Explosion: Challenges for Bioethics
Bioethics and the Law

Samer B. Korkor

, 11/26/2012

Deepwater Horizon Explosion: Challenges for Bioethics

(Bioethics and the Law) Permanent link

On November 15, the Department of Justice announced that BP Exploration and Production Inc. agreed to plead guilty to 11 counts of felony manslaughter, one count of felony obstruction of Congress, and violations of the Clean Water and Migratory Bird Treaty Acts, as a result of the explosion in the Gulf of Mexico of the Deepwater Horizon oil rig, maintained by BP, which killed 11 people, injured 17 others, and caused the largest environmental disaster in U.S. history.  BP agreed to pay a record $4.5 billion in criminal fines and penalties, the largest criminal resolution in U.S. history. 

But what does this mean for the field of bioethics?  The BP oil spill raises issues that fall squarely within the field’s domain, including public health and the ethical use of technology. 

The explosion was a result of BP’s insufficient controls on high-tech equipment that dropped five miles before piercing the earth to gulp petroleum from beneath the sea-floor. Without doubt, the Gulf of Mexico’s ecology will be permanently impacted by the 35,000 to 65,000 barrels of oil per day that leaked from a sea-floor oil gusher for 56 days, triggered by the explosion. 

Along with the environmental damage, the BP oil spill created a multiplicity of public health concerns.  Crude oil contains a mixture of carcinogens such as volatile hydrocarbon compounds. Before allowing volunteers to venture near the oil spill, BP required participants to sign a waiver of liability, which stated that exposure may lead to numerous, and potentially fatal, health risks.  According to Marylee Orr, Executive Director for Louisiana Environmental Action Network (LEAN), those exposed to the oil experienced dizziness, headaches, nausea, and rapid heart beat. Other effects to exposed individuals, who include but are not limited to fishermen and clean-up volunteers, continue to be explored.  For example, PAHs have been proven to cause tumors in laboratory animals that have inhaled the fumes from these substances.  However, at the time of the spill, local public health officials determined that respirators were not required for oil clean-up crews. 

The ethical questions surrounding the public health implications of the BP spill are numerous.  What was the ethical obligation to ensure the health and safety of those who were exposed to the oil?  Was there a unique obligation to offer them access to any kind of specialized medical care?  If so, on whom does the responsibility fall – the government, insurance companies, BP, or some combination thereof?  Furthermore, similar to informed consent questions encountered in other settings, one might consider whether the waiver of liability that BP provided adequately informed individuals of the health risks, alternatives, and consequences of participation.  Were the circumstances under which people signed the forms free of coercion or conflicts of interest?

The use of advanced technology that serves to alter the natural world also raises significant concerns.  The BP spill is not the only disaster caused by the use of advanced technology, and it will probably not be the last one.  As history has progressed, so have human technologies to alter the natural order in ways that were previously unimaginable.  And thus, traditional ethical questions arise – how should humanity utilize technology in a way that protects human values, but does not hinder scientific advancement?  This debate is as relevant to embryonic stem cell research as it is to the creation of drills with the ability to stretch for miles in search of petroleum and other natural resources. 

Many companies rely on developing technology for large oil companies in order to secure a financial profit, and many companies specialize in manufacturing technologies that impact the environment, and as a result, public health. What are the ethical considerations that must be addressed when, or before, creating this kind of nature-altering technology?  The interdisciplinary expertise that already lies within the bioethics community can greatly help to inform the framework for ethical concerns raised by the BP spill.  For example, the spill raises broad philosophical questions, such as: What sort of moral values guide the human relationship with nature?  Are there obligations to protect nature?  If so, what are they?  International and cross-cultural observations regarding approaches to the environment may lead to a better understanding of the ethical considerations across countries and cultures.

As the global demand to harness the environment’s energy to power modern life is increasing, the ethical debates that surround the BP experience are vast.  

Samer B. Korkor is a lawyer in Washington, D.C. 

Posted by Susan Gilbert at 11/26/2012 12:39:37 PM | 


Comments
Your wide lace top motifs ended up pinned, presented way up along with employed using stab stitching every single two or three millimetres all-around every single wide lace top pattern.
Posted by: chockckc@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 2/17/2014 1:26 AM


The end result, with everyone's expected, but as long as the Cheap Gucci Belt men's basketball team in the game play out their own level, beautiful can process nature is also satisfactory. Yi jianlian scored 30 points, since yao Ming, another had 30 points or more Cheap Gucci Belt players in the Replica Belts, in under the gaze of yao Ming, he not only inherited yao flag, also took the leader's scepter. Nearly 4 years, [url=http://www.y-sharing.com/gucci/replica-gucci-belts/]http://www.y-sharing.com/gucci/replica-gucci-belts/[/url] interviewed yi countless times, but also because of an interview with him, went to the United States in the two seasons, he step by step to improve progress, as a witness, I also can realize the maturity of an athlete is not easy. I am not friends with yi jianlian, but professional working relationship, but it does not hinder I feel happy for him. Looking forward to the next, he can continue to have such a play, for their won a new contract in the NBA. Interview after the game, yi jianlian said very well, he didn't want to talk too much personal, indeed, the Cheap Gucci Belt men's basketball team is made up of 12 players, are related to their success or failure, it is a unity of collective, they are willing to also can share the pressure for yi. I start next few games full of expectation, I hope like a world championship in 2010, everything is possible. No assignment at night, and didn't go to the basketball game, but went to aquatic center, the scene to watch the swimming competition. Practiced for five years as a swim, I swim or have certain feelings, but to be honest, I was a child, swimming are anathema to me. Because of swimming, I scold by coach, by dad, winter will jump into the icy pool, the other children is rest over the weekend, but I still want to go to training. Competitive sports itself is not evil, [url=http://www.adagenciesinaction.org/]Gucci Belt Replica[/url] evil is the training system, no happiness. gucci belt aquatic center capacity should be is greater than the water cube, the reporter position is also very much, but it is still cannot meet the demand, therefore, we haven't the Replica Belts started, swimming final event is listed as one of the high demand, reporters not only have to have an interview with documents, also need to national gucci belt committee (ioc) to apply for admission. Tickets are divided into two kinds, with and without the table of the table, all I got is without the table, it doesn't matter, now that is going to play soy sauce, put the table to is should be more people in need. See the swimming at the scene, it's not clear watching TV, but now that came to the scene, nature is feeling atmosphere, and the heart of I am a witness also make people happier. Gold medal, really is not so important, the atmosphere is very warm, no matter which country's athletes appearance, can be a big cheers. Last game man nature is the most exciting, [url=http://www.seexinjiang.com/]Cheap Ferragamo Belts[/url] 4 x100m freestyle relay this project as striking as men's 4 x100m relay race, Michael Phelps, luo chet team USA for the gold medal was determined, however, they come back by France in the last bar, I don't know the name of France four player [url=http://www.levriersetcieentreamis.com/]http://www.levriersetcieentreamis.com/[/url] s, but they are really great, all clapping and cheering for them, too. Ceremony is also in a happy atmosphere, I had a special watch Phelps, cut and the expression of special people, they smile, just ROM chet laugh too stiff, yes, he is swimming last time was caught a, can happy rise? Competitive sports sometimes, regret is always inevitable, but no matter how many person, it seems the word shame shall not be with athletes, in addition to the athletes through improper means to obtain benefits for themselves. Again a few days, the London Replica Belts is about to end,, Cheap Gucci Belt team gold MEDALS are take about the sa [url=http://www.freepokerphotossite.com/]http://www.freepokerphotossite.com/[/url] me, I don't take the time to look at the game everywhere, may regret for the rest of your life. Come to London for so many days, just far visited London bowl, didn't have a chance to get in. One day morning, have the men's 110 m hurdles heat, liu xiang gave me a reason to get up early. Track and field is the 10 o 'clock in the morning, the day when I went into the London bowl, the scene has been filled, the feeling is really shocking. Track and field as the mother of sports, is a concern. To be honest, I don't like track and field games, for all the TV in track and field games, I would change channels. Think, liu xiang gave us a lot of people a reason to look at track and field. Another im [url=http://www.wrdefenderfootball.com/]http://www.wrdefenderfootball.com/[/url] portant reason is that don't like track and field, since the childhood, have seen, participated in various school track and field games, has long vexed. At that time, I've been looking [url=http://www.freepokerphotossite.com/]Replica Gucci Belts[/url] forward to the school to do a swimming, so I can cut a dash, this desire until college. Liu xiang was arranged in the sixth group, group 1 have shi dongpeng, but he ran, 7 will clearly for the semi-finals. The Replica Belts should be full of the milk of human kindness, but the louis vuitton belt is also a cruel, especially in track and field on such a project, it is easier to be amplified. After shi dongpeng elimination, group 2 has an athlete false start, he was sent out by the referee directly. Training for so long time, not far from the mountains came to London, so of final outcome, is very cruel. Unexpectedly, more cruel is yet to come, that's right, say is liu xiang injured out of the race. To see liu xiang's game, I think, is probably don't have time to watch the final, look at the preliminary contest is good also, this is my first time to see liu xiang at the scene, as fellow, nature also looking forward to he can run well. But who also have never thought, liu xiang in the first column when it fell down, and in addition to shock, I can only has no language. The same number 1356, the same third, also the first shot, 4 years, liu how to step into the same river.
Posted by: mbtning@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 7/15/2014 3:53 AM


I cant wait to read more from you. This is really a great blog.
Posted by: caiwwhh@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 11/26/2014 3:43 AM