The Hastings Center Report

September - October 2014

Vol. 44, No. 5

Highlights

Editor's Podcast

This podcast player requires theAdobe Flash plug-in. You may also download the MP3 file via the podcast feed.


Subscribe

Order the Hastings Center Report
Of Kinks, Crimes, and Kinds: The Paraphilias Proposal for the DSM-5
Science and Society

Alice Dreger

, 02/19/2010

Of Kinks, Crimes, and Kinds: The Paraphilias Proposal for the DSM-5

(Science and Society) Permanent link

When is a kinky interest really sick?

That’s the central question the Paraphilias Sub-Work Group of the American Psychiatric Association has had to face as they’ve developed proposed revisions for the DSM-5. Pity those given the task of trying to figure out how, when, and why to medicalize or de-medicalize everything from asexuality to zoophilia (the latter being the sexual interest known to less progressive types as bestiality).

Looming over the whole task is the ugly history of the pathologizing of homosexuality. As I teach my students every year, it took until 1973 for the American Psychiatric Association to stop officially categorizing all forms of homosexuality as mental disorders. And that official demedicalization happened not because a happy and spontaneous consensus emerged that the science supported the change, but because gay psychiatrists understandably had had enough.

Nowadays, you can find self-appointed representatives of every sexual interest who will try to align their history with homosexuality, because, like the gay psychiatrists of the early 1970s, they want out of the DSM. The bondage folks, the zoophiles – even the pedophiles want out. At least the vocal ones do. They’ll tell you that, like gay men and lesbians, they never should have been in the book in the first place.

I would have been watching the progress of the Paraphilias Sub-Work Group regardless; as an historian of sexuality, I’m professionally fascinated to see where it will all go. But as it turns out, I’ve had something of a ringside seat, because my friend Ray Blanchard has been serving as the chair of the sub-work group.

Ray and I met over a paraphilia a few years ago. (It wasn’t as exciting as that may sound. I was writing a history about a controversy over autogynephilia, a paraphilia Ray articulated, investigated, and named.) In the last year, I’ve been witnessing Ray’s struggle over the challenge of coming up with a scientifically sound, clinically helpful revision of the DSM-4’s mess.

I’ve only been able to watch Ray’s generalized struggle, and not to hear many of the details. The work was embargoed until a few days ago, when it was thrown open to the public for comment. It’s been a little like waiting for a friend’s baby to be born, and I find myself now counting its fingers and toes to see what we’ve got. And maybe it’s just because I’ve been waiting a long time for this baby and one of its four parents is my friend, but I think what we’ve got here is pretty viable.

The central shift strikes me as really smart: the sub-work group has proposed distinguishing between paraphilias and paraphilic disorders. Whereas the DSM-4 made all paraphilias sick, the DSM-5 proposal seeks to recognize a difference between the harmless and the harmful.

Under the revision, the foot fetishist who keeps getting arrested because he steals shoes, who fondles the feet of unconsenting women strangers, and who can’t hold a job because he’s too busy obsessing about his next sexual opportunity – he’s got a paraphilic disorder. The foot fetishist who is happy, comfortable, and functions fine – he just has a paraphilia.

What exactly is a paraphilia? Ray has defined it as “any intense and persistent sexual interest other than sexual interest in genital stimulation or preparatory fondling with phenotypically normal, consenting adult human partners.” I realize that definition is probably a turn-off, but that’s scientific language for you. Basically what this means is that a paraphilia is a general term for sexual kinks.

The move in the DSM proposal is a subtle way of saying sexual kinks are basically okay – so okay, the sub-work group doesn’t actually bother to define paraphilia. But a paraphilic disorder is defined: that’s when an atypical sexual interest causes distress or impairment to the individual or harm to others.

I asked Ray about the logic behind this interesting move. He explained to me, “We tried to go as far as we could in depathologizing mild and harmless paraphilias, while recognizing that severe paraphilias that distress or impair people or cause them to do harm to others are validly regarded as disorders.”

Some critics will say that the sub- work group amounts to a ship of fools because they are trying to draw lines that don’t really exist in nature. Human sexuality is so complicated, human sexual history so irregular, how can you hope to say what is merely kinky and what is really sick? How can you say whether the heartsick foot fetishist is mentally disordered?

I put this to Ray, and I found his answer reasonably pragmatic: “The Paraphilias Sub-Work Group recognized from the outset that there are many shades of grey between typical sexual behavior, paraphilias, and paraphilic disorders. The important thing for us was distinguishing between benign paraphilias versus paraphilic disorders that cause real anguish to the individual or predispose the individual to violate the rights of other people or harm them in serious ways.”

There are still critics who think that the DSM is no place to deal with sexual variety. For example, the physician and sexologist Charles Moser, who has had a long-time interest in S&M, has taken this position – that the so-called paraphilias, no matter how harmful to self or others, have no place in the DSM. Moser understands that a pedophilic act is a crime, but he argues (with Peggy Kleinplatz) “that the removal of pedophilia from the DSM would focus attention on the criminal aspect of these acts, and not allow the perpetrators to claim mental illness as a defense or use it to mitigate responsibility for their crimes. Individuals convicted of these crimes should be punished as provided by the laws in the jurisdiction in which the crime occurred.”

The problem I see with Moser’s approach is that, in the guise of being progressive, it is actually pretty draconian. Moser doesn’t seem to understand that there are men who might be thought of as “responsible pedophiles” – men with pedophilic interests who stop themselves from acting on those interests. Under Moser’s approach, there seems to be no avenue for a “responsible pedophile” to legitimately seek medical attention in his attempts to avoid committing a crime. If you completely demedicalize all paraphilias, there seems to be no straightforward way for a clinician to reasonably seek, for example, to use hormones to chemically flatten the libido of the “responsible pedophile” so that he will not feel much urge to act on his interests.

Moreover, I don’t get why, under Moser’s logic, sexuality has some kind of almost magical power to it, such that it can make acts that most people would see as really harmful merely hot. Imagine, for example, a man likes to beat his wife black-and-blue. She says she consents to the beatings. As I understand Moser, if sexual stimulation results, then we should simply congratulate the couple on their fabulous relationship and walk away.

And what about sadistic rapists who abduct, torture, and even kill strangers? Are we really supposed to believe such people are criminals but they aren’t mentally ill? I’m not saying these criminals should be absolved of punishment, but surely such people are seriously sick by anyone’s reasonable definition. To deny that – whether it is done in the service of sexual liberation or in the hopes of appropriately punishing criminals – is just making medicine a slave to social politics.

Critics of the DSM’s inclusion of any paraphilic disorders sometimes claim that the DSM adds stigma to their identities. This may be true in some circumstances, and as a long-time critic of sexology’s effects on sexual minorities, I’m sympathetic to the concern. But I also admit I find it hard to believe that the little old lady on the street corner who is freaked out by the leather-decked guy walking by with his dog-collared-and-leashed human sex slave is freaked out because she checked the DSM. Although it would be good if the DSM writers did not intentionally add stigma to anyone’s life – and I think the proposed paraphilias revision actively seeks to avoid unnecessary stigma of kinks – it is not really their job to make everyone feel proud of their identities.

Historically speaking, many identities have indeed gone the way of homosexuality: from being understood as a sin, to a crime, to a pathology, to a proud identity. But that doesn’t mean all forms of sexuality should go all that way, especially not forms that involve sex with a person who cannot consent (as a child cannot) or has not consented (as a rape victim has not). For some sexual varieties, rather than drawing a parallel to the history of homosexuality, it might make more sense to draw a parallel to something like the history of alcoholism.

Drunkenness was once understood simply to be a sin. Then it became a crime. Then a medical problem. Many alcoholics now see their alcoholism as the basis of an essentialized identity – they call themselves alcoholics even when they have not drunk alcohol for 30 years.

But no sensible person would see alcoholism as simply a matter of political identity, one whose pull to indulge should be proudly pursued, complete with celebratory parades. A drinking problem can, after all, lead to real harm to oneself and to others. The very reason recovering alcoholics embrace the identity is because they recognize alcoholism as a serious disorder.

It might make a lot of sense to think of sexual interests like pedophilia as being akin to alcoholism. That is not to say we should put the DSM-5 to bed and forever cease thinking about how best to categorize, manage, and treat sexual varieties in medicine and in culture. I think, unlike some past groups, the DSM-5 sub-work group has enough humility to recognize their work will someday need to be revised again. But it is to say I think the DSM-5 proposal for distinguishing paraphilias from paraphilic disorders offers what medicine is supposed to offer: the prospect of maximizing help while minimizing harm.

 

Posted by Susan Gilbert at 02/19/2010 08:55:42 AM | 


Comments
Dr. Dreger grossly misrepresents my perspective as she defends her colleague, Ray Blanchard. Allow me to set the record straight. I have consistently said that many people have problems with their sexual interests and may need the assistance of mental health professionals. The difference is that I believe that the DSM diagnoses should be based upon science, not the “I think this is sick” school of thought, which really is pretty draconian. If the DSM committee is willing to admit there is no science behind their pronouncements, I have no issue with whatever they include. Although that means the DSM just becomes an APA opinion poll and that is what they fear.

For the record, those foot partialists (not fetishists), who cannot resist stealing shoes, suffer from kleptomania, or a compulsive disorder, or an impulsive disorder, or a whatever disorder. An interest in feet is the wrong focus of treatment, so why include it in the diagnosis. Individuals who wash their hands 500 times a day may have a disorder, but it is not a hand washing disorder. Dreger’s example of diagnosing the consensual BDSM couple is quite confused, because they would not be diagnosable under Blanchard’s new criteria either. I do see plenty of “responsible pedophiles” in my practice and have no problem prescribing anti-androgens as well as other treatment modalities. The issue is how does submitting an insurance bill with pedophilia as the diagnosis help anyone. I do think this is an important debate, but it needs to a respectful debate, not a diatribe.

Charles Moser, PhD, MD, FACP
Posted by: docx2@ix.netcom.com ( Email | Visit ) at 2/20/2010 1:17 PM


I welcome readers to read Dr. Moser's article to see for themselves whether I have misrepresented his position. Indeed, I hotlinked it in my article so that readers could easily read Dr. Moser's position for themselves. Just link on the red word "argue" in the article. I do not believe I have misrepresented the position but welcome further discussion.
Posted by: a-dreger@northwestern.edu ( Email ) at 2/21/2010 1:51 PM


The distinctions between "paraphilias" and "paraphilic disorders" that DSM-V Paraphilias subworkgroup is proposing is really not as progressive as they are trying to sell it as. Sure, they tell us that the purpose of this is to make sure that such "atypical" sexual interests aren't mental disorder if they don't cause the person any problems. And that would be a step forward if it wasn't for the fact that this has already been what the DSM has said since 1994. Given that this was accomplished 16 years ago, making such a distinction really isn't really a step forward at all. What the paraphilia-paraphilic disorder distinction amounts to is a way to get what people admit to be non-pathological sexual interests into the major classification of mental disorders and refer to them with a term that has been used to designate those interests as mental disorders since DSM-III was published in 1980. This strikes me as a step backwards, not forward.

If it's not a mental disorder, what business does the DSM have in classifying it (V codes aside)? One of the major arguments against including ego-dystonic homosexuality in DSM-III was that it singled out this particular sexual orientation as being somehow problematic. Since DSM-III-R, there haws been a NOS diagnosis for people distressed about their sexual orientation without mentioning any particular sexual orientation. Why not do something similar with the "paraphilias"? This is something the Dr. Moser has elsewhere proposed--"Sexual Interest Distress." By classifying only certain sexual interests in the DSM and not others, it creates a fundamental asymetry that reflects an inherently negative value judgment on those interests.

Another argument against including ego-dystonic homosexuality in DSM-III is that if someone distressed about their homosexual urges comes to a clinician, why is a diagnosis of ego-dystonic homosexuality necessary? It was argued that depression or an anxiety disorder would seem more appropriate. (See Spitzer and Bayer's "Edited correspondence on the status of homosexuality in DSM-III.")

In the case of sadistic rape, given that there are lots and lots of people who practice BDSM with consenting adults, why should that rapist's problem being classified according to his sexual interest? Perhaps he does have a mental disorder, but it would make more sense to me to call it anti-social personality disorder or perhaps an impulse control disorder.

This is, of course, similar to Dr. Moser's argument regarding the foot partialist.
Posted by: ahinder2@uiuc.edu ( Email ) at 2/24/2010 11:40 AM


Very interested in how DSM-5 will turn out.
Posted by: tyciol@hotmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 12/3/2010 2:14 AM


I would rather read 'can not legally consent' as opposed to 'can not'. Consent is not complex, informedness is, on the other hand, but that is an adjective to be added.
Posted by: tyciol@hotmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 12/3/2010 6:08 AM


So much of all this is dependent on the cultural zeitgeist. On what basis do we go from classifying a behavior as an identity (and calling it science), especially the ones cited here, i.e., homosexuality, alcoholism, pedophilia. This implies that we know scientifically that all are inborn, immutable, and by extension untreatable. In the case of alcoholism and pedophilia the best we can hope for is "managing" them so they don't cause harm, in the case of homosexuality its just accepted now that this is the person's identity. While there's no science to support this, is it somehow easier to deal with an identity rather than a behavior that could be potentially harmful? If so, can't the same thing be said for the morbidly obese person who can't stop eating chocolate cake?
Posted by: maninsync@yahoo.com ( Email ) at 12/2/2012 6:59 PM


Extremely details specifically the last part I care for such information and facts much. I was searching for this certain details for some time
Posted by: chenghuiaa123456@163.com ( Email | Visit ) at 5/15/2013 1:44 PM


Are randomly scattered with elastic tied up on a side, immediately turns into a rock star. Long soft hair, need not deliberately, let the messy scattered over his shoulders.
Posted by: orologireplica2013@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 7/30/2013 11:48 PM


I’m impressed, I must say. Really rarely do I encounter a blog that’s both educative and entertaining, and let me tell you, you have hit the nail on the head. Your idea is outstanding; the issue is something that not enough people are speaking intelligently about. I am very happy that I stumbled across this in my search for something relating to this.
Posted by: magyblog@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 8/16/2013 2:33 PM


This is a really super post. Must admit that you are amid the best writer I have read. I appreciate your making the effort to discuss this class of article
Posted by: nitinkhare246@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 8/18/2013 8:16 AM


Has been in a leading position in a number of patents, its watches are handcrafted at the factory used, adhere to quality, beautiful, reliable tradition of excellence
Posted by: orologireplica2013@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 9/30/2013 5:01 AM


This is often a highly awesome post. Can I use this on my internet site? Also, though I'm here I'd like to see if you would like to take a look at my web page about producing money on the web. I'm positive there is a number of pointers on there that you'd like. Thanks!
Posted by: plumptondgx@hotmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 4/13/2014 6:11 AM


This is often a highly awesome post. Can I use this on my internet site? Also, though I'm here I'd like to see if you would like to take a look at my web page about producing money on the web. I'm positive there is a number of pointers on there that you'd like. Thanks!
Posted by: plumptondgx@hotmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 4/13/2014 6:15 AM


I'm impressed, I must say. Very rarely do I come across a website both informative and entertaining, and let me tell you, you've hit the nail on the head. Your blog is important; the issue is something that not enough people are talking intelligently about.
Posted by: onlysolo@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 6/1/2014 1:41 PM


This web page can be a stroll-via for qscvbnkloi all of the information you wanted about this and didn’t know who to ask. Glimpse right here, and you’ll undoubtedly uncover it.
Posted by: rodneysingle716@hotmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 6/13/2014 3:14 AM


It is a multi-cuisine restaurant serving dishes from Continental, Chinese and Indian cuisines. The famous dish of this restaurant is chow mein served with Chinese gravy chicken or vegetable. This restaurant is located inside the famous Hotel Coorg International, which is an essential part of Coorg Tourism, and this is one of the reasons for its popularity.
Posted by: simondoul170@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 6/23/2014 9:22 AM


Your topic is amazing.Looking forward to hearing from you again asap.Thanks for your sharing.
Posted by: rodneysingle716@hotmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 7/31/2014 5:16 AM


Achieving wellness, as well as staying healthy, is surely an energetic process. All-natural health is based on prevention, and on retaining your body along with minds in good shape. Wellness lies in evening out these kind of aspects in the body by way of a program comprising diet regime, exercise, along with regulation of the emotions. The last of these kinds of is simply too often disregarded any time wellbeing guidance is dispensed, but sometimes use a pronounced impact on bodily well-being.
Posted by: myahaloms@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 10/15/2014 11:30 AM


Every day, possibly even it seems like, a new study signifies that several part of life-style -- physical activity, diet program, alcohol consumption, etc * has an effect on health and endurance. Fitness and health is nice physical health, and is the effect of frequent exercise, proper diet along with nourishment, as well as correct sleep with regard to bodily restoration.
Posted by: myahaloms@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 10/15/2014 11:31 AM


Walking is a great physical exercise and will be incorporated into your entire day. Try out airport parking within the farthest place as an alternative to nearest area probable. Please take a number of journeys round the supermarket along with your wagon just before starting your own shopping. Almost all of the useful during winter a few months in colder climates. Holding the acquisitions to your car instead of pressing all of them out in a new basket assists boost muscle tone in addition to providing you with an cardiovascular workout.
Posted by: eronenisme@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 10/15/2014 9:28 PM


There are numerous methods, by means of which you can improve your life-style. First of all, to reside in the kitchen connoisseur, you should improve your eating habits. You need to aware of what type and exactly how significantly meals you happen to be eating and in exactly what manner the meal has been well prepared. Decrease the intake of toast and also hot and spicy food stuff along with replace it using more vegetables, fresh fruits and grains. It really is much healthier to be able to grill or heavy steam your meal, simply because this will assist to sustain the natural vitamin supplements, which can be within the meal.
Posted by: janice.merkoward@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 10/19/2014 3:00 AM


Goal setting is usually crucial in order to truly be successful. Take note of the lasting goals, and then arranged month to month, every week as well as every day ambitions. Research your targets day-to-day and make the eyes as well as thoughts centered on all of them.
Posted by: janice.merkoward@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 10/20/2014 11:43 AM


Spend some time to plan and make preparations daily along with invest in healthy eating as well as organizing healthy recipes. Shop at an industry which will help your primary goal, and make preparations healthy food which will help one's body not really towards that. Pick up healthful goodies and also drinks that may additionally benefit you. Remember, it does not take little things that are the most important.
Posted by: janice.merkoward@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 10/20/2014 11:43 AM


A great deal of movie star chefs these days are generally recommending the usage of extra virgin olive oil. If you wish to start dwelling and maintaining a healthy lifestyle, keep this in mind on your next food excursion.

Organic olive oil is best famous for lowering the probability of cardiovascular diseases. Other accounts furthermore claim that that lowers the potential risk of malignancies too.
Posted by: jenn.tenner2@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 10/26/2014 6:35 PM


In addition, what can you accomplish concerning antifreeze, indication oil, strength prescribing water, and also generator essential oil water leaks on the front yard and also storage area ground? The typical cleaning chemicals which are utilised are usually harsh, very alkaline dramas as well as hydrocarbon-based products that aren't appropriate for a healthy lifestyle.
Posted by: boni.experius@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 10/27/2014 6:08 PM


These kind of solvents are usually poisonous to be able to human beings, as soon as your trickle is cleaned, the particular toxin-soaked rags are generally pitched in to a waste materials could as well as plastic box pertaining to removal inside a dump. In effect then, the thing is being moved at first to a new location at your residence (carry your own breathing!), just after to be deposited within a land fill with excellent long-term expenditure towards the community. Enzyme and also bacterial environmentally friendly washing items provide a means to fix break down your automotive liquids properly along with successfully. The thing is resolved (or perhaps "dissolved as well as degraded") both at home and could be laundered absent with a little typical recipe cleaning soap as well as h2o.
Posted by: boni.experius@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 10/27/2014 6:08 PM


Green cleaning merchandise employing nutrients may also be used inside pools and also doctor offices. That they emulsify and also break down skin oils, brown lotions as well as other natural contaminants, keeping the normal water obvious and also eliminating the particular host surroundings or substrate that would let the plankton to develop.
Posted by: boni.experius@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 10/27/2014 6:09 PM


Using digestive support enzymes in this manner increases the kitchen connoisseur by reduction of the amount of chemical compounds, like chlorine, necessary to keep the h2o clean and therefore really helps to decline the inside effects of making use of people substances including biting, watery face and scratchy dermititis. In addition, the use of a great enzyme-based natural cleansing program helps maintain the particular filtering collections obvious by next environmentally friendly strategy can conserve the buyer time and expense.
Posted by: boni.experius@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 10/27/2014 6:09 PM


One more use for a green cleaning technique involving nutrients and bacteria that is not generally identified is as earth hair conditioners with regard to grass along with gardens. Using plant foods yearly can be, the bottomline is, useless and your money - and may effect a healthy lifestyle in a bad means. This is simply not to mention the particular run-off that goes in the water ways, waters along with ponds that offer drinking water. Simply by using a dirt conditioner (digestive support enzymes and also surfactants derived from bacteria), it is possible to aerate and also oxygenate the particular soil in turn, wearing down the actual complex nutrients, eating the actual plant life along with turf start by making your nutrition effortlessly assimilated by the origins.
Posted by: boni.experius@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 10/27/2014 6:10 PM


A sound body just isn't something you purchase from a drug shop or perhaps a variety store, but could be practiced by practicing group styles associated with health-related behavior, based on choices produced from available alternatives. Third , common sense, if you would like realize the benefits of the home chef, you need to replicate several healthy routine as a part of your day-to-day or even each week actions, a number of styles similar to good nutrition and exercising. Some other advantages involves: Reduced medical costs, diminished illness and injuries, decreased medical doctors go to, Keeps an individual used as well as enhanced employee/employer interaction
Posted by: eronenisme@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 10/30/2014 5:06 AM


Therefore, as you may observe, you receive considerably more management, if you plan your current food preparation plus your food shopping. The next of the healthy lifestyle ideas is to learn organizing the days out and about dining. Start by learning about well balanced meals eating places in your town. Have a look at his or her promotions, savings and other circumstances to reap the benefits of. And then begin preparing your own evenings away or maybe your going out to restaurants inside individuals dining places.
Posted by: jenn.tenner2@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 10/31/2014 2:32 PM