Pregnant
women and their interests have been underrepresented in health research. Little
is known about issues relevant to women considering research participation
during pregnancy. We performed in-depth interviews with 22 women enrolled in
either one of two trials sponsored by the National Institutes of Health to assess
the safety and immunogenicity of the H1N1 vaccine during pregnancy. Three
themes characterized women’s decisions to participate in research: they valued
early access to the vaccine, they perceived a safety advantage when
participating in research, and they wanted to help advance scientific
knowledge. However, there were also some considerations that would disincline them
to participate in research—for instance, a significant risk of maternal or
fetal harm, the presence of a placebo arm in a study, or a requirement to
significantly change planned therapy or behavior. Pregnant women who
participated in the H1N1 vaccine trials viewed research favorably, citing its
advantages over standard clinical care. These findings emphasize that access to
benefit should guide policy for including pregnant women in research.
Key words/concepts: human subjects
research, pregnancy, research ethics, qualitative research, risk/benefit
Pregnant
women and their interests have been underrepresented in health research. Little
is known about issues relevant to women considering research participation
during pregnancy. We performed in-depth interviews with 22 women enrolled in
either one of two trials sponsored by the National Institutes of Health to assess
the safety and immunogenicity of the H1N1 vaccine during pregnancy. Three
themes characterized women’s decisions to participate in research: they valued
early access to the vaccine, they perceived a safety advantage when
participating in research, and they wanted to help advance scientific
knowledge. However, there were also some considerations that would disincline them
to participate in research—for instance, a significant risk of maternal or
fetal harm, the presence of a placebo arm in a study, or a requirement to
significantly change planned therapy or behavior. Pregnant women who
participated in the H1N1 vaccine trials viewed research favorably, citing its
advantages over standard clinical care. These findings emphasize that access to
benefit should guide policy for including pregnant women in research.
Key words/concepts: human subjects
research, pregnancy, research ethics, qualitative research, risk/benefit