Why I am Suspicious of Bioethics
Bioethics

Emi Koyama

, 02/18/2010

Why I am Suspicious of Bioethics

(Bioethics) Permanent link

Intersex Initiative and I join other intersex activists, bioethicists, scholars, and Advocates for Informed Choice a national legal organization that advocates for children born with intersex conditions (or disorders of sex development) in challenging the apparent large-scale "research" involving hundreds of pregnant women and their fetuses without institutional review board approval or oversight.

The questionable "research" practice, discussed recently in Bioethics Forum, involves the off-label prenatal administration of dexamethasone, a synthetic hormone, to women who are carrying a fetus suspected of having congenital adrenal hyperplasia (CAH). While CAH often requires life-long monitoring and medication, the prenatal dexamethasone treatment does not alter any of the medical concerns. It is solely intended to address a cosmetic issue, which is to prevent the fetus girls from developing an enlarged clitoris.

A letter of concern, signed by bioethicists and other scholars, asks whether de-facto human subject research is being conducted without IRB oversight, and whether the main practitioner of this treatment is providing less than complete information about what it accomplishes and its potentially hazardous effects. We agree with their assessment, and endorse their call for an official investigation and redress.

That said, I confess that I have become increasingly suspicious of the field of bioethics and the role its experts play in the larger machinery of medical science. My suspicion began when I became involved in the controversy over the so-called "Ashley X" case, in which a six-year old girl with severe developmental and ambulatory disabilities was put through a series of medical treatments that involved hormone therapy to stop her physical growth, along with the removal of her breast buds and uterus.

In 2007, lawyers from Washington Protection and Advocacy System (now Disability Rights Washington) concluded that the procedures violated Washington state laws because it sterilized Ashley without court approval. University of Washington's Seattle Children's Hospital acknowledged the error, and pledged to change course. It seemed like a major victory for the disability rights movement, which viewed the treatment as an erosion of the human rights of people with disabilities, especially women with disabilities who used to be routinely sterilized without consent.

But the story did not end there: the university established a working group consisting of experts from various fields of medicine, as well as legal scholars, disability theorists, and bioethicists, which in less than two years publicly announced a new standard and cleared the way for hospitals to offer "growth attenuation" as an option for parents requesting such treatment for their children. According to Ashley's parents, who quote an e-mail they received from a participant at a recent pediatrics conference at least 10 doctors around the country have offered growth attenuation "therapy."

As with the challenge to the Ashley treatment, scholars may be right to challenge the mass administration of dexamethasone as a case of unauthorized human subject research in violation of institutional policies and professional code of ethics. But I feel that these criticisms do not go far enough to question the ideologies about the female body and normalcy that such treatments simultaneously presume and uphold.

The scholars' statement alleges that the doctor administering dexamethasone to hundreds of women violated regulatory procedures for research oversight, but from my perspective, this concern seems, at best, peripheral.

While the scholars point out that the intended "benefit" of the dexamethasone administration is "to avoid a cosmetic issue associated with CAH," it does not take a stance on the ethical and social implication of avoiding such cosmetic issues in the first place. Since genital virilization is itself not an illness requiring medical intervention, and society does not generally endorse using off-label medications to alter the shape of medically healthy fetal body parts, why is it that the central criticism of this procedure is that it lacks IRB oversight?

Another troubling aspect of the treatment is that it exemplifies the extent to which pregnant women in our society are expected to sacrifice their own needs and wants to produce a perfect baby. Legitimate research on the long-term effects of prenatal dexamethasone exposure in children is still in early stages (with some indication that it may be linked to problems with cognitive development), but it has been established that many women taking dexamethasone suffer considerably, spending much of their pregnancy feeling sick. Still, our society expects pregnant women to do what medical experts say it takes to give birth to a perfect baby, and they are often blamed when something goes "wrong."

The scholars’ letter does argue that women should be fully informed of "risks they assume for themselves and on behalf of their future children," but the emphasis is clearly on the fetuses. Thus it does not question the unreasonable expectation that society places on pregnant women to be selfless incubator for their fetuses.

I oppose the dexamethasone treatment primarily because its goal – suppressing natural human variations that do not cause illness or pain – is suspect, and because it preserves a social and cultural environment that is inhospitable for people with intersex conditions. In particular, because women are typically advised to take dexamethasone when they have already given birth to an older child with CAH, I worry what the treatment would mean for the older child, especially if the child is an older sister. I am further concerned about the enormous pressure pregnant women are under to produce perfect babies, and the moral judgment that follows the birth of a child with disabilities or atypical physique.

I applaud signers of the "letter of concern" for calling attention to this problematic medical "treatment," but I fear how the situation might appear to someone seeking the treatment, or even to a casual observer. On one side is a courageous doctor giving immediate assistance to women without being bogged down by bureaucracies; on the other is a group of ivory tower academics nitpicking on technicality.

The investigation into the "Ashley treatment" cumulated in the admission by the University of Washington and Seattle Children's Hospital that they violated the state anti-sterilization law. But it did not lead to the end of or greater restraint on the questionable medical intervention designed to permanently infantilize young children with severe developmental disabilities.

I fear that the campaign to hold the main propagator of the dexamethasone treatment accountable would, if not accompanied by sustained challenges to more fundamental problems with this treatment, also result in creating a more "ethical" means of continuing the treatment – that is, a means that complies better with the established procedures and codes of ethics – rather than stopping it.

I am starting to question seriously what role bioethics and bioethicists play in medical controversies involving children who cannot make decisions for themselves, and parents, especially mothers, who are forced to make the decision under complicated social, cultural and economic circumstances – growth attenuation is promoted as a solution to parents' hardship of taking care of their child without adequate public assistance. Does a medical treatment become "unethical" because it violates an established policy or law, or because it accommodates and abets social prejudices against those deemed "abnormal." rather than addressing a legitimate medical problem?

I feel that bioethics is moving away from the disability rights movement, women's health movement, and other movements seeking social justice in medicine, and instead is offering consulting services and grand rounds speakers to smooth things over so that the same problematic treatments can continue to be performed "more ethically." "We don't tell doctors what to do," I heard one bioethicist explain at a symposium on growth attenuation therapy. "We simply advise how it should be done."

I know that many of the scholars who signed the letter on the dexamethasone treatment do, in fact, tell doctors what to do (and what not to do) out of their commitment for the rights of people with disabilities, women, children, and others often mistreated by medicine. I believe that several of them would agree with me that the prenatal application of any medical technology solely to prevent socially stigmatized cosmetic variation is wrong, regardless of the toxicity of the treatment. After all, what is the relevance of risk/benefit analysis when the intended goal is unethical?

In that sense, I trust many of these scholars and their judgment. But that was how I felt about the disability theorists who were part of the working group that ended up helping to polish up growth attenuation as a legitimate treatment. Continued vigilance is needed to make sure that bioethics maintains a commitment to social and economic justice and rejects involuntary body modification as a substitute for overcoming societal prejudices.

Emi Koyama is the director of Intersex Initiative, an advocacy organization for people born with intersex conditions.

 

Posted by Susan Gilbert at 02/18/2010 10:36:13 AM | 


There are certainly a lot of details like that to take into consideration. That is a great point to bring up. I offer the thoughts above as general inspiration but clearly there are questions like the one you bring up where the most important thing will be working in honest good faith. I don?t know if best practices have emerged around things like that, but I am sure that your job is clearly identified as a fair game. Both boys and girls feel the impact of just a moment’s pleasure, for the rest of their lives.
Posted by: magyblog@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 8/16/2013 2:33 PM


Ce site est vraiment un rendez-vous par le biais de tout ce que vous voulez savoir, ne savent pas à qui s'adresser pour obtenir des informations. Entrevoir ici, vous le trouverez.
Posted by: chenghuiaa123@163.com ( Email | Visit ) at 1/15/2014 3:10 AM


Just a smiling visitor here to share the love (:, btw outstanding pattern .
Posted by: smkn4bengkulu@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 6/3/2014 11:50 AM


Not so bad for us...
Posted by: smartmil888@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 9/8/2014 3:35 PM


Changes which can be made to any kind of way of life can be done without priced at a lot of money. The truth is, many of these alterations might lower your expenses.
Posted by: oyahaloms@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 11/9/2014 7:19 AM


One of them of the healthy change that may save big money every year can be using tobacco.
Posted by: oyahaloms@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 11/9/2014 7:19 AM


I offer the thoughts above as general inspiration but clearly there are questions like the one you bring up where the most important thing will be working in honest good faith
Posted by: ayunksyah@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 12/24/2014 2:51 AM


Spend less associated with organically grown foodstuff by buying in large quantities in which it feels right through buying your own items entire as opposed to pre-cut. For instance, payable a smaller amount for 2 or perhaps Three or more red sweet peppers if you purchase these people if they're whole rather than investing in a package which can be pre-cut.
Posted by: oyahaloms@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 2/3/2015 5:26 PM


Keeping mentally and physically match does not mean plowing against each other health and fitness club as well as playing enormous weight training to maintain a new trim along with healthy system. The general idea can be leveraging someone's activities every day from your straightforward go walking in order to straightforward strength training afterwards.
Posted by: eronenisme@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 3/3/2015 3:05 PM


Ginseng is one of a lot of exceptional herbal products pertaining to metabolism operate, memory enhancement, improving attention, reducing stress as well as boosts levels of energy.
Posted by: jenn.tenner2@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 4/19/2015 4:20 PM


l'affichage des vues sur les sites de laisser la page blog web écrivains savent qu'ils ont participé quelque chose d'utile pour le monde du Web complète.
Posted by: fatahiqbal@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 4/20/2015 10:49 PM


These types of furnishings is often accompanied to bits of household furniture including a coffee table or even end platforms, shelving for books and residential entertainment holders.
Posted by: eronenisme@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 4/25/2015 11:17 AM


Regardless, regular visits for you to ones vet will be the Least complicated prevention AND observing your dogs behavior from home.
Posted by: alex.yahaloms@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 4/28/2015 2:38 PM


anyone won't recognize much information about your current rescue's medical history, therefore get him to a vet Any time possible regarding a great check-up.
Posted by: alex.yahaloms@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 4/28/2015 2:38 PM


I hаvе beеn іn loоk fоr оf ѕоme information abоut іt аlmoѕt threе time. Yоu served mе а lot іndeed аnd analyzing thіs уour publish I hаve fоund mаnу nеw аnd uѕеful information abоut thiѕ topic.
opportunity seekers email list
http://freshemailsdaily.com/buy-opt-in-email-lists.html
Posted by: lenovodell637@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 5/7/2015 7:44 AM


Narcissism and self-pity are equally detrimental and extreme to one's pursuit of pleasure. But at times white and black thinking causes us to be assume that we have to make a choice from the 2. I see them as two different manifestations of the same process, however.
Posted by: boni.experius@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 5/8/2015 12:40 PM


I read your article a couple of times. Your views are in accordance with my own for the most part. This is great content for your readers....

webpage design
Posted by: jamalasjhar34@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 5/11/2015 2:54 AM


Excellent read, Positive site, where did u come up with the information on this posting?I have ead a few of the articles on your website now, and I really like your style. Thanks a million and please keep up the effective work
seo service
Posted by: lenovodell637@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 5/12/2015 4:06 AM


I hаvе beеn іn loоk fоr оf ѕоme information abоut іt аlmoѕt three time. Yоu served mе а lot іndeed аnd analyzing the уour publish I hаve fоund mаnу nеw аnd uѕеful information abоut this topic.



where to unlock your phone
Posted by: jamalasjhar34@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 5/25/2015 3:30 AM


I hаve read аll the comments аnd suggestions posted bу the visitors fоr this article are vеrу good,We wіll wait fоr уour nеxt article so only.Thanks!
seo
Posted by: lenovodell637@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 5/25/2015 9:37 AM


I hаve read аll the comments аnd suggestions posted bу the visitors fоr this article are vеrу good,We wіll wait fоr уour nеxt article so only.Thanks!

neopoints for sale
Posted by: jamalasjhar34@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 5/28/2015 8:23 AM


We are really grateful for your blog post. You will find a lot of approaches after visiting your post. Great work.
cough remedies
Posted by: lenovodell637@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 6/8/2015 2:52 AM


The guidelines may come as a surprise to people who are still puzzling out the ethical arguments.
key west jet skis
Posted by: aarijali100@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 6/9/2015 6:47 AM


A and B are asked to guess who will now do better than in his first test.
packers and movers pune rates
Posted by: aarijali100@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 6/10/2015 8:07 AM


Your views are in accordance with my own for the most part. This is great content for your readers....
family law attorneys sacramento
Posted by: lenovodell637@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 6/14/2015 7:27 AM


Yоu served mе а lot іndeed аnd analyzing thіs уour publish I hаve fоund mаnу nеw аnd uѕеful information abоut thiѕ topic.
mi40x book
Posted by: lenovodell637@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 6/17/2015 7:17 AM


Hello, I have browsed most of your posts. This post is probably where I got the most useful information for my research.
belly fat burners that really work
Posted by: robinjack529@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 6/20/2015 12:13 AM


I recently found many useful information in your website especially this blog page. Among the lots of comments on your articles...
Injustice Hack
Posted by: lenovodell637@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 6/21/2015 3:43 AM


Thanks for taking the time to discuss this, I feel strongly about it and love learning more on this topic. If possible, as you gain expertise, would you mind updating your blog with extra information? It is extremely helpful for me. http://www.mypsychicadvice.com/
Posted by: lenovodell637@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 6/22/2015 7:25 AM


Caterina va in citta’ who bombards us with her classical music. And then there is Marta from ‘Tutta la vita davanti’ Olma Writings Blogger Outreach
Posted by: blackmen12345@yahoo.com ( Email | Visit ) at 6/24/2015 3:21 AM


The guidelines may come as a surprise to people who are still puzzling out the ethical arguments. twitter verified accounts
Posted by: lenovodell637@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 6/25/2015 4:51 AM


It is solely intended to address a cosmetic issue, which is to prevent the fetus girls from developing an enlarged clitoris.Pull your ex back review
Posted by: blackmen12345@yahoo.com ( Email | Visit ) at 6/28/2015 6:02 AM


We offer professional quality translation services for clients all over the world. Our expert team work with 100% reliability, accuracy and timeliness. Online Language Translation...photo
Posted by: blackmen12345@yahoo.com ( Email | Visit ) at 6/29/2015 8:33 AM


Great write-up, I am a big believer in commenting on blogs to inform the blog writers know that they’ve added something worthwhile to the world wide web!..Verified Tumblr accounts
Posted by: lenovodell637@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 6/30/2015 6:46 AM


This article was written by a real thinking writer. I agree many of the with the solid points made by the writer. I’ll be back. capacitive touch screens
capacitive touch screens
Posted by: lenovodell637@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 7/4/2015 8:12 AM


I hаve read аll the comments аnd suggestions posted bу the visitors fоr this article are vеrу good,We wіll wait fоr уour nеxt article so only.Thanks!
Manual blog comments
Posted by: lenovodell637@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 7/8/2015 6:04 AM


I definitely enjoying every little bit of it. It is a great website and nice share. I want to thank you. Good job! You guys do a great blog, and have some great contents. Keep up the good work.
GTA cheats
Posted by: lenovodell637@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 7/11/2015 7:30 AM


I definitely enjoying every little bit of it. It is a great website and nice share. I want to thank you. Good job! You guys do a great blog, and have some great contents. Keep up the good work.

https://www.rebelmouse.com/thevenusfactorreviewsdiet/
Posted by: jamalasjhar34@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 7/14/2015 5:09 AM


I needed to much obliged in your time for this sublime read!! I decidedly getting a charge out of every tad bit of it and I have you bookmarked to look at new stuff you weblog post...
Free PDFs
Posted by: lenovodell637@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 7/14/2015 7:31 AM


It appears as though spent lots of time and effort in your blog. I’ve saved it and i’m searching toward reading through new articles.
Info
Posted by: lenovodell637@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 7/15/2015 5:53 AM


I definitely enjoying every little bit of it. It is a great website and nice share. I want to thank you. Good job! You guys do a great blog, and have some great contents. Keep up the good work.
vitamin for memory
Posted by: lenovodell637@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 7/16/2015 11:52 PM


You have done a great job on this article. It’s very readable and highly intelligent. You have even managed to make it understandable and easy to read. You have some real writing talent. Thank you.
movers in fort worth
Posted by: lenovodell637@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 7/21/2015 5:38 AM


Great website here, really useful and interesting information. Thanks a lot for all your efforts, and please keep the great work up!
24 hr plumbing
Posted by: lenovodell637@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 7/23/2015 4:57 AM


While CAH often requires life-long monitoring and medication,
loft conversions london
Posted by: robinjack10@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 7/25/2015 6:08 AM


I am also having a hard time getting my readers to leave comments. Analytics shows they are coming to the site but I have a feeling “nobody wants to be first”
loft conversions hammersmith
Posted by: robinjack10@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 7/25/2015 6:30 AM


The betting slip is highly functional with the excellent feature of being able to automatically lock in higher odds should the odds shift in your favour before the bet is processed.
Airsoft Gun Pistols
Posted by: lenovodell637@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 7/25/2015 9:12 AM


The betting slip is highly functional with the excellent feature of being able to automatically lock in higher odds should the odds shift in your favour before the bet is processed.
best netent reviews
Posted by: lenovodell637@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 7/26/2015 3:53 AM


I am sure they will be profit by this site. Really I read it yesterday however You have made an awesome showing.
Read Full Report
Posted by: lenovodell637@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 7/28/2015 8:01 AM


In 2012, Accel Partners, one of the initial funds in Facebook or Linkedin, called the gates of Supercell and joins its shareholders. In April of 2013 another group of investors 'startups' specialists (Index Ventures, IVP...) carried out a round that valued Supercell at 700 million.
http://www.pre-hackedgames.net/clash-of-clans-hack/
Posted by: ses90172@cdnqa.com ( Email | Visit ) at 7/28/2015 8:26 AM


In 2012, Accel Partners, one of the initial funds in Facebook or Linkedin, called the gates of Supercell and joins its shareholders
Teater Dating com
Posted by: robinjack10@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 8/1/2015 3:39 AM


Seriously.. many thanks for starting this up. This site is one thing that is required on the web, someone with some originality!
Draftkings
Posted by: jamalasjhar34@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 8/1/2015 7:47 AM


who plan to introduce additional legislation that will further protect homeowner’s right to utilize solar energy.
lovetraction lines ebook
Posted by: robinjack10@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 8/2/2015 7:25 AM


It is very important keep in mind that almost all cougar girls vary.
Posted by: janice.merkoward@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 8/2/2015 3:14 PM


Every one has different passions as well as personalities. Nonetheless, a common theme between cougar girls is because they tend to be sophisticated and relish the finer things in life (which include beautiful young guys).
Posted by: janice.merkoward@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 8/2/2015 3:14 PM


I needed to much obliged in your time for this sublime read!! I decidedly getting a charge out of every tad bit of it and I have you bookmarked to look at new stuff you weblog post...

https://www.rebelmouse.com/thevenusfactorreviewsdiet/
Posted by: jamalasjhar34@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 8/4/2015 5:00 AM


tad bit of it and I have you bookmarked to look at new stuff you weblog post.
Ejaculation Guru Free Download
Posted by: robinjack10@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 8/4/2015 6:23 AM


volunteers and new initiatives in the same niche. Blog gave us useful information to work. You have done an amazing job!
loft conversions london
Posted by: robinjack10@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 8/8/2015 1:39 AM


the local authority, City of Clarkson Valley, tried to implement a bill banning the installation of solar panels on properties.
loftplan liquidation
Posted by: robinjack10@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 8/8/2015 2:18 AM


I really like the humor your publish has offered. I loved this website a great deal. Keep posting article such as this. It's fun. Nice photography too !
about dslr cameras
Posted by: lenovodell637@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 8/8/2015 7:42 AM


Seriously.. many thanks for starting this up. This site is one thing that is required on the web, someone with some originality!
dofollow backlink service
Posted by: lenovodell637@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 8/9/2015 6:17 AM


Greetings! Very helpful advice in this particular article! It's the little changes that produce the greatest changes. Thanks a lot for sharing!

hay day hack
Posted by: jamalasjhar34@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 8/11/2015 5:42 AM


This site is one thing that is required on the web, someone with some originality!
best price memory foam mattress
Posted by: lenovodell637@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 8/11/2015 7:20 AM


sound the alarm bells. Inspect the sentence thoroughly and try splitting it into multiple sentences.
Xtreme Fat Loss Diet Ebook
Posted by: robinjack10@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 8/13/2015 3:42 AM


The post is written in very a good manner and it contains many useful information for me.
Watch Series Online on MovieTube
Posted by: lenovodell637@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 8/13/2015 6:36 AM


Greetings! Very helpful advice in this particular article! It's the little changes that produce the greatest changes. Thanks a lot for sharing
where to get instagram followers
Posted by: lenovodell637@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 8/15/2015 8:43 AM


The scholars' statement alleges that the doctor administering dexamethasone to hundreds of women violated regulatory procedures for research oversight
packers and movers pune to hyderabad
,
Posted by: aarijali100@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 8/17/2015 3:09 AM


Leave a comment
Name *
Email *
Homepage
Comment