Mammography and the Corporate Breast
Medicine and Business

Adriane Fugh-Berman and Alicia Bell

, 11/24/2009

Mammography and the Corporate Breast

(Medicine and Business) Permanent link

The U.S. Preventive Services Task Force (USPSTF) would seem as unlikely a target for attack as Santa’s elves. For a quarter-century, this squeaky-clean, underappreciated group of doctors and nurses who are specialists in preventive medicine has toiled away in obscurity in the selfless service of public health.

Appointed by the Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality, the task force panel is independent and does not take costs into consideration; it evaluates only the risks and benefits of preventive medicine strategies. The task force must be reeling over the vicious reaction to its latest recommendations regarding screening mammography.

The guidelines are based on an exhaustive analysis of recent studies from Sweden, the United Kingdom, and the U.S. Breast Cancer Surveillance Consortium involving a total of more than 830,000 women, and a specially commissioned study funded by the National Cancer Institute in which six separate teams studied the risks and benefits of 20 screening strategies through mathematically modeling.

The panel recommended against routine screening mammograms for women 40-to-49 years old, and screening every two years for women 50 to 74. These not-exactly-radical recommendations are almost identical to the World Health Organization guidelines, which recommend screening every one-to-two years between ages 50 and 69.

Because mammography is less effective at distinguishing cancers from normal breast tissue in premenopausal women, mammograms miss cancers in some younger women and raise a false alarm in others. This can cause real harm; one woman may ignore a cancerous lump because her mammogram was normal; another may undergo an unnecessary surgical procedure because her mammogram was suspicious. As Cornelia Baines, a physician-epidemiologist at the University of Toronto once pointed out, “… A benign biopsy is not a benign experience”; a statement supported by the medical literature.

A Carcinogenic Test

Unlike Pap smears and prostate exams, mammography is not a benign screening technique. Mammograms utilize x-rays and are known to increase the lifetime risk of breast cancer, especially in younger women. A case-control study in 1,742 women under the age of 50 with breast cancer found that, compared to 441 controls, multiple mammograms five or more years prior to diagnosis almost doubled breast cancer risk. A U.K. study estimated that annual breast cancer screening starting at age 40 would increase radiation-induced breast cancer mortality by 0.5 per 100 women screened. That’s five times the increase in radiation-induced breast cancer mortality when annual screening started at age 50 (0.11 per 100 women screened).

Mammograms are far more accurate in women over 50, and so the benefits outweigh the risks. Mammography is also a useful tool in younger women with suspicious lumps or a family history of breast cancer.

So who most vociferously attacked the task force? The themes and terms used by the critics are eerily similar.

“Unnecessary Deaths”

Carol H. Lee, chair of the American College of Radiology Breast Imaging Commission, said to Reuters that the recommendations "ignore the valid scientific data and place a great many women at risk of dying unnecessarily."  In the same article, Daniel Kopans, a Harvard professor of radiology, said the new guidelines "are scientifically unjustified and will condemn women ages 40 to 49 to unnecessary deaths from breast cancer."  W. Phil Evans, president of the Society of Breast Imaging, told Reuters, “These recommendations are inconsistent with current science and apparently have been developed in an attempt to reduce costs. Unfortunately, many women may pay for this unsound approach with their lives."  

In the American College of Radiology press release, James H. Thrall, chair of the group’s Board of Chancellors, said “…we are moving toward a new health care rationing policy that will turn back the clock on medicine for decades and needlessly reverse advances in cancer detection that have saved countless lives". The Access to Medical Imaging Coalition warned in a statement to the Washington Post that the task force recommendations will "turn back the clock on the war on breast cancer.”  Otis Brawley, chief medical officer of the American Cancer Society, wrote in a Washington Post op ed, “Turning back the clock will add up to too many lives lost”.

In the same op ed, Brawley said the task force “took a step backward in the fight against breast cancer.”  Evans said in a statement, "The USPSTF recommendations are a step backward and represent a significant harm to women's health".

Some critics apparently believe that avoiding “confusion” is a rationale for rejecting facts. James H. Thrall, quoted in the Washington Post, called for rescinding the task force’s recommendations "to avoid confusion as health-care reform moves forward." Robert Schmidt, a professor of radiology at the University of Chicago Medical Center told the Chicago Tribune that, “It’s wrong to keep changing recommendations and give conflicting messages to women.” In the Washington Post, Kopans cites “the confusion and anxiety that this has created.” Len Lichtenfeld, the American Cancer Society's deputy chief medical officer, told the Associated Press, "Our concern is that as a result of that confusion, women may elect not to get screened at all."

Conflicts of Interest

Are you starting to wonder whether these players are reading from the same script book? Vague, fact-free, emotionally charged statements are the language of public relations, not scientific discourse. The striking similarities in word choice among these critics could be entirely coincidental. Perhaps the congruence in their conflicts of interest is coincidental as well.

U.S. Preventive Services Task Force members are not allowed to have “substantial conflicts of interest, whether financial, professional, or other conflicts, that would impair the scientific integrity of the work of the USPSTF." Organizational or personal conflicts of interest, however, are common among critics.

Donors to the American Cancer Society Cancer Action Network (ACS CAN), the “nonprofit, nonpartisan advocacy affiliate of the American Cancer Society”, include Hologic, which makes breast imaging products, and Johnson and Johnson, which makes an image-guided breast biopsy product. Donors to the American College of Radiology Imaging Network (ACRIN) Fund for Imaging Innovation include Siemens, GE Healthcare, Phillips, Hologic, and many others that make mammography machines or related products.

According to the American College of Radiology Web site, “the leaders of the ACR and ACRIN have been meeting with industry leaders from key donors to the ACRIN Fund to strengthen the relationships between the organizations and better determine how both parties can maximize this relationship.” The Society of Breast Imaging is an organization managed by the American College of Radiology.

The Access to Medical Imaging Coalition is run by Tim Trysla, who works for the Alston and Bird law firm and is counsel to the “largest complex diagnostic imaging manufacturers, physician groups and providers regarding Medicare reimbursement.” He directs the “Coalition of Diabetic Providers and Manufacturers opposing Medicare competitive bidding for durable medical equipment.” Daniel Kopans holds patents on imaging systems. Robert Schmidt reports receiving royalties from, and being a shareholder in Hologic.

Absent any actual scientific basis for opposition, critics combine fact-free fear-mongering with general attacks on the task force. “It’s arrogant and irresponsible,” said Schmidt in the Chicago Tribune. "It's crazy – unethical, really" said Kopans.

The bogeyman of rationing is raised. Lee said to Reuters, “These new recommendations seem to reflect a conscious decision to ration care”.  Kopans said in the same article, “…I am afraid their decision is related to saving money rather than saving lives."

None of these conflicts of interest have been mentioned in news coverage. Unnecessary mammography leads to unnecessary surgical procedures – and exposes women to radiation that can increase breast cancer risk. Current breast cancer detection methods are not safe or effective enough to justify their use in millions of younger women.

Fear-mongering from organizations with vested interests is preventing a public dialogue stressing that what we really need are better detection methods, especially for young women who have more time to develop radiation-induced cancers. Rather than touting an ineffective, possibly dangerous screening method, we need better diagnostic methods for younger women. As Cindy Pearson, executive director of the National Women’s Health Network (one of the few national health advocacy groups that takes no money from industry) said, “We need a Pap test for breast cancer.”

In the meantime, a clear-eyed scientific assessment of what works and what doesn’t work is needed not only for breast cancer screening but for all diagnostics and therapeutics. Mammography makes money for the people and organizations that have created this sham of a controversy. When critics with conflicts of interest are banned from the argument, the controversy vanishes.

Adriane Fugh-Berman, M.D., is an associate professor in the department of physiology and biophysics at Georgetown University Medical Center, and director of PharmedOut, an independent project based at Georgetown that educates physicians about inappropriate pharmaceutical company influence on prescribing practices. Alicia M. Bell is the project manager and research assistant for PharmedOut, as well as a member of the board of directors of the National Women's Health Network.

 

Posted by Susan Gilbert at 11/24/2009 12:55:17 PM | 


Comments
Dr. Fugh-Berman and Ms. Bell explore the problematic connection between women's breasts and money to be made by imaging, biopsy and treatment for breast cancer. But with a profit-geared health care system as we have now, these sorts of considerations might apply to most medical decisions.

Breast cancer screening, early detection and effective treatment is, as I see it, one of the few triumphs of medical oncology. Like some forms of lymphoma, leukemia, and a few other "solid" tumors, breast cancer cells usually respond to chemotherapy and radiation. By contrast, some other cancers types are routinely treated aggressively, and at considerable cost, without reasonable hope for cure. By contrast, breast cancer, when found early, is highly-treatable and even curable in the majority of cases.

The Task Force findings are limited, not because of the extraordinary number of cases analyzed or the squeaky-cleanness of the panel members, as described above, but by the antiquity of the data and by their stated irrelevance to digital mammography (the better technology for women less than 50 years.)

Perhaps if we could disconnect the profit motive from health care provision, such as through a single-payer health care plan with salaried physicians, people could focus on the straight medical data – the facts and figures about a particular procedure or treatment, however limited - without worrying that someone's just trying to make a buck.
Posted by: Elaine Schattner, M.D. ( Email | Visit ) at 12/17/2009 7:58 AM


I am often to blogging and i really appreciate your content. The article has really peaks my interest. I am going to bookmark your site and keep checking for new information.
Posted by: magyblog@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 8/16/2013 2:36 PM


Most scientific inquiry resolution trail person of twin approaches it can be either qualitative or quantitative. Fitness custody examination is frequent based on quantitative patterns in which, by description, info is quantifiable. That is, the unequals worn in inquiry are deliberate furthermore recorded as numerical information that can be analyzed by norms of statistical implements.
Posted by: wiki.wify@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 3/5/2014 1:26 AM


There are so many different aspects when it comes to this topic. Thank you so much for sharing your knowledge on this particular aspect.
Posted by: Jessica2z0@outlook.com ( Email | Visit ) at 9/22/2014 12:24 PM


This topic has always fascinated me. Thank you for writing an article that has great content and is well written. Well I am inspired by your writing style.
Posted by: Dominic2z0@outlook.com ( Email | Visit ) at 9/23/2014 11:59 AM


however, you ought to change the proteins and ensure you will get enough supplements and do not brief your self any nutrition. You understand the ultimate way to diet regime actually is to view your fat and calories consumption. Ingesting smaller portions in far more instances during the morning would be the good for you. It enables one's body of burning every single supper consume rather then keeping this for later or perhaps turning it to be able to excess fat.
Posted by: orkooper@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 11/17/2014 5:54 AM


Did you check out the recent research on Breast Cancer Screening & Detection! I am really hopeful this would turn things around!...
Posted by: lifeisfun1977@yahoo.com ( Email | Visit ) at 12/23/2014 1:46 AM


Thanks for sharing this ideas, I really appreciate your article..
Posted by: firecruch@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 2/5/2015 5:22 PM


some many great ideas in this post, just keep going... Thanks
Posted by: firecruch@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 2/26/2015 4:56 PM


thanks for his information
Posted by: ririncantik0@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 4/13/2015 4:37 PM


dfgfdg
Posted by: fatahiqbal@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 4/20/2015 10:45 PM


I hаvе beеn іn loоk fоr оf ѕоme information abоut іt аlmoѕt threе time. Yоu served mе а lot іndeed аnd analyzing thіs уour publish I hаve fоund mаnу nеw аnd uѕеful information abоut thiѕ topic.
email managers
http://freshemailsdaily.com/send-bulk-email.html
Posted by: lenovodell637@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 5/7/2015 7:43 AM


Supplements as well as essential nutrients are really important to your overall health, and also standing on the top of this may let you stay a fantastic living....

OLD SCHOOL NEW BODY CUSTOMER SERVICE
Posted by: jamalasjhar34@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 5/10/2015 7:35 AM


Excellent read, Positive site, where did u come up with the information on this posting?I have ead a few of the articles on your website now, and I really like your style. Thanks a million and please keep up the effective work
high pr backlinks
Posted by: lenovodell637@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 5/12/2015 4:02 AM


really not so good for us...
Posted by: smartmil888@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 5/12/2015 3:50 PM


Supplements as well as essential nutrients are really important to your overall health, and also standing on the top of this may let you stay a fantastic living....

cheapest unlock codes
Posted by: jamalasjhar34@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 5/25/2015 3:29 AM


A and B are asked to guess who will now do better than in his first test.filipino channel
All B's and most A's say that B will.
Posted by: robinjack529@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 5/25/2015 7:01 AM


I hаve read аll the comments аnd suggestions posted bу the visitors fоr this article are vеrу good,We wіll wait fоr уour nеxt article so only.Thanks!
enter logic seo
Posted by: lenovodell637@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 5/25/2015 9:34 AM


Is it cheating for students to take a drug to enhance their ability to learn difficult material or stay awake to study for a big test...

neopoints
Posted by: jamalasjhar34@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 5/28/2015 8:22 AM


Disini kegunaan kulit buah manggis bereaksi dengan meluruhkan kumpulan lemak yang menyumbat di pembuluh darah. Setelah normalnya timbunan lemak tersebut, sehingga peredaran darah menuju jantung akan kembali sehat.
targeted opt email
Posted by: lenovodell637@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 6/1/2015 4:50 AM


The guidelines may come as a surprise to people who are still puzzling out the ethical arguments.
key west jet skis
Posted by: aarijali100@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 6/9/2015 6:47 AM


Positive site, where did u come up with the information on this posting..
packers and movers pune rates
Posted by: aarijali100@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 6/10/2015 8:07 AM


Having vegetables and fruit similar to broccoli, oatmeal, and also tomatoes are shown to be great for the center.
used cars idaho falls
Posted by: aarijali100@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 6/23/2015 2:49 AM


Thank you for the great article I did enjoyed reading it, I want to encourage that you continue your great job, USA twitter accounts
Posted by: lenovodell637@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 6/25/2015 4:49 AM


Thanks for the tips, maybe I can use this svelte my noesis marketing and Ive been use whatsoever ethnical media in try a interaction
Battlefield Hardline PC Download Game
Posted by: aarijali100@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 6/29/2015 6:18 AM


However, this is conversing with the intense. Until you happen to be currently in times exactly where you are dealing with 50+ lbs you may be thinking that you don't have much to bother with.
Posted by: oyahaloms@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 7/1/2015 4:34 PM


To be described as a little chubby -- problem. You will find a whole lot worse matters in life compared to having the capacity to pinch an inch : fine, probably 2 in case you are gonna be sincere.
Posted by: oyahaloms@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 7/1/2015 4:34 PM


You have in mind learning more about conditioning and also want to look at steps to enhance your health however today, you merely do not have the period. You have various other commitments you must accomplish 1st so when the means occurs, then you'll concentrate on your overall health and conditioning.
Posted by: oyahaloms@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 7/1/2015 4:34 PM


The rate is the percentage of working-age people who are looking for a job or already have one
Ginefiv
Posted by: robinjack10@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 7/5/2015 2:40 AM


I hаve read аll the comments аnd suggestions posted bу the visitors fоr this article are vеrу good,We wіll wait fоr уour nеxt article so only.Thanks!
Manual blog comments
Posted by: lenovodell637@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 7/8/2015 6:03 AM


It's amazing how much science can change a lot of things. thanks a lot ;)
Posted by: putlockers5@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 7/11/2015 3:35 PM


I definitely enjoying every little bit of it. It is a great website and nice share. I want to thank you. Good job! You guys do a great blog, and have some great contents. Keep up the good work.
VENUS FACTOR REVIEWS
Posted by: jamalasjhar34@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 7/14/2015 5:08 AM


I definitely enjoying every little bit of it. It is a great website and nice share. I want to thank you. Good job! You guys do a great blog, and have some great contents. Keep up the good work.
enhance your brain
Posted by: lenovodell637@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 7/16/2015 11:52 PM


Awesome and interesting article. Great things you've always shared with us. Thanks.Just continue composing such informative posts.
san francisco moving companies
Posted by: lenovodell637@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 7/21/2015 4:47 AM


Your blog provided us with valuable information to work with. Each & every tips of your post are awesome. Thanks a lot for sharing. Keep blogging,
plumming
Posted by: lenovodell637@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 7/23/2015 8:31 AM


I recently found many useful information in your website especially this blog page. Among the lots of comments on your articles. Thanks for sharing..

medical marijuana boulder
Posted by: jamalasjhar34@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 7/25/2015 8:40 AM


You actually make it look so easy with your performance but I find this matter to be actually something which I think I would never comprehend.

no exam life insurance policy
Posted by: jamalasjhar34@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 7/27/2015 4:15 AM


I prefer to read quality content, so happy to find good place to many here in the post, the writing is just great, thanks for the post...

water plumbing
Posted by: jamalasjhar34@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 7/27/2015 7:16 AM


We are unique in that we enjoy traveling together and we like to hang out outside of volleyball as well.
family law cases
Posted by: lenovodell637@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 7/27/2015 7:42 AM


Great post I would like to thank you for the efforts you have made in writing this interesting and knowledgeable article.
how do you refinance your car
Posted by: lenovodell637@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 7/28/2015 4:44 AM


This is a good post. This post gives truly quality information. I’m definitely going to look into it. Really very useful tips are provided here. Thank you so much. Keep up the good works...

average auto insurance rates
Posted by: jamalasjhar34@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 7/28/2015 6:46 AM


Your article has piqued a lot of positive interest. I can see why since you have done such a good job of making it interesting.
more
Posted by: lenovodell637@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 7/28/2015 7:45 AM


This is just the information I am finding everywhere. Thanks for your blog, I just subscribe your blog. This is a nice blog.
housing inspector
Posted by: lenovodell637@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 7/29/2015 8:02 AM


This is a good post. This post gives truly quality information. I’m definitely going to look into it. Really very useful tips are provided here. Thank you so much. Keep up the good works..

learn more here
Posted by: jamalasjhar34@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 7/29/2015 8:06 AM


vHowever, is still among the leading topics of our time. I appreciate your post and look forward to more.
100% High PR unique domains
Posted by: robinjack10@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 7/30/2015 6:15 AM


We are really grateful for your blog post. You will find a lot of approaches after visiting your post. I was exactly searching for. Thanks for such post and please keep it up. Great work

buy silagra
Posted by: jamalasjhar34@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 7/30/2015 7:18 AM


Connect with the Forum

Get Permissions

RSS feed