The Octuplets: An Insurance Story
Health Policy

Stephen Latham

, 02/13/2009

The Octuplets: An Insurance Story

(Health Policy) Permanent link

By now, you’ve probably heard all about the California octuplets: born via in vitro fertilization to an unemployed single mom who already had six IVF kids, born at birth weights varying from one pound eight ounces to three pounds six ounces, requiring hundreds of thousands of dollars worth of NICU care. Editorial writers and some bioethicists are using the births to justify a call for strict regulation on the number of embryos that can be transferred to a uterus in a single cycle. The California Medical Board is launching an investigation into whether the multiple transfers violated standard of care.

Fertility clinicians are defensively pointing out that guidelines from the American Society for Reproductive Medicine (ASRM) already recommend single embryo transfers for healthy, younger patients, and limit transfers for older and less healthy patients, depending up their conditions. These clinicians also point out that the number of multiple births from IVF in the United States has declined significantly in recent years. Finally, some commentators have argued that the fertility clinicians do not bear sole responsibility for the multiple births in the octuplet case: the mother was offered selective reduction when her multiple pregnancy was first detected, and she declined.

So, there you have it: another classic insurance story.

Permit me to explain. In the United Kingdom, Belgium, and the Scandinavian nations, for example, the number of transfers permissible in IVF pregnancies has been sharply limited, either by state regulation or by professional standard-setting that appears to have more bite than the ASRM standards do here. But in those countries, too, the IVF process, including transfer attempts, is covered by national health insurance. If the physician transfers only a single embryo into the woman’s uterus and there is no implantation, he simply has another go—at no additional expense to the infertile couple.

A few states in this country have similar regulations: they mandate private insurance coverage for IVF, and then either make limits on the number of embryos transferred a condition of insurability, or require IVF providers to comply with the ASRM guidelines. But only 15 states require insurance coverage of any kind for infertility, and many of those either sharply limit coverage for IVF or exclude it entirely.

The result is predictable, given the high cost of IVF. If they can only afford, or their insurance will only cover, a single cycle, many couples—and their clinicians—feel that the best odds of achieving pregnancy involve multiple transfers. Like fertile couples, couples who’ve had trouble with infertility often want more than one child—and there, too, the economics favor shooting for twins in a single cycle, rather than paying for two cycles of singleton births. That’s undoubtedly an important part of why 53 percent of American women undergoing IVF treatments in 2005 transferred three or more embryos. And the predictable consequence of multiple transfers, even given the availability of selective reduction, is multiple birth. The octuplet story is just an extreme version of a much more common story, and that common story has its roots in the problem of insurance coverage.

What’s more, the same story can be told about ovarian stimulation, another cause of multiple births. Lack of insurance coverage may bias couples to go forward with fertilization even in the presence of multiple eggs, because they don’t want to have to pay for, or can’t afford, another attempt.

Of course, the absence of IVF insurance doesn’t explain the whole of the multiple-birth phenomenon. Some clinicians may view multiple transfers as a way to enhance their success rates. Some couples’ desire for twins isn’t driven by the economics of IVF treatment. And some women may be strongly motivated to limit the number of times they go through any invasive fertility procedure. But the fact remains: without insurance coverage, strict regulations capping the number of embryos transferred in a cycle will severely limit the reproductive options of couples who can’t afford multiple attempts at pregnancy. With insurance coverage, such regulations would not be nearly so burdensome.

And that’s why the octuplets story is another classic insurance story.


Posted by Greg Kaebnick at 02/13/2009 08:22:13 AM | 

After study a few of the blog posts on your website now, and I truly like your way of blogging. I bookmarked it to my bookmark website list and will be checking back soon. Pls check out my web site as well and let me know what you think.
Posted by: ( Email | Visit ) at 8/16/2013 2:44 PM

Love this story about insurance. You have the insightful thought.
Posted by: ( Email | Visit ) at 9/25/2013 10:33 PM

Great write-up, I am regular visitor of one's blog, maintain up the excellent operate, and It's going to be a regular visitor for a long time
Posted by: ( Email | Visit ) at 6/1/2014 12:11 PM

sans aucun doute votre information est très fiable et sa très intéressante également, la lecture du début à la fin était vraiment bon et j'ai obtenu des renseignements très précieux, merci pour le partage de ce poste, je vais continuer à lire et partager cela.
Posted by: ( Email | Visit ) at 9/12/2014 5:57 AM

Replica Gucci Belts,Fake Gucci Belt,Gucci Belts Cheap,Cheap Gucci Belts
Posted by: ( Email | Visit ) at 11/11/2014 2:47 AM

thanks for his information
Posted by: ( Email | Visit ) at 4/13/2015 4:51 PM

I hаvе beеn іn loоk fоr оf ѕоme information abоut іt аlmoѕt threе time. Yоu served mе а lot іndeed аnd analyzing thіs уour publish I hаve fоund mаnу nеw аnd uѕеful information abоut thiѕ topic.
blackberry mep unlock code calculator
Posted by: ( Email | Visit ) at 5/7/2015 6:57 AM

You made some decent points there. I looked on the internet for the issue and found most individuals will go along with with your website..
Posted by: ( Email | Visit ) at 5/10/2015 7:20 AM

In the allergy medication ad, when they get to talking about how the drug may cause dry mouth, we could see the allergy-prone woman with the magical weeds growing inside her mouth....

extra resources
Posted by: ( Email | Visit ) at 5/11/2015 6:09 AM

Scent of varied manufacturers tend to be popular having persons affecting various age ranges. Fashion experienced persons world-wide monitor the modern bunch connected with fragrance start out there. In actuality fragrances perform large location.
high pr backlinks
Posted by: ( Email | Visit ) at 5/12/2015 3:52 AM

Nice blog right here! Also your website quite a bit up very fast! What web host are you using? Can I am getting your affiliate hyperlink on your host? I want my web site loaded up as quickly as yours..

learn more
Posted by: ( Email | Visit ) at 5/12/2015 6:47 AM

What’s more, the same story can be told about ovarian stimulation, another cause of multiple births

delhi to jaipur cab
Posted by: ( Email | Visit ) at 5/13/2015 2:06 AM

If it became entrenched, such thinking could open the door to other and more insidious forms of genetic reductionism.
Free Ebook Downloads
Posted by: ( Email | Visit ) at 5/14/2015 6:18 AM

Henry Greely and six other prominent authors published a commentary

pest control
Posted by: ( Email | Visit ) at 5/20/2015 6:51 AM