Liberals and Their Ill-Liberal Policies

 Daniel Callahan

, 05/11/2006

Liberals and Their Ill-Liberal Policies

 Permanent link

I am sometimes baffled by my fellow liberals in their social priorities. Why, for instance, does stem cell research receive such political support, and money, while many more pressing needs exist in this country? At the same time that the ballot initiative in California won $3 billion in state bonds to initiate a stem cell research program, the media there was reporting that there are 2.5 million illiterate adults in that state. There is plenty of experience on successfully teaching adults to read, plenty of evidence that an adult illiterate has an almost hopeless economic future in this country, and plenty of evidence that a literate citizenry makes a far greater economic and social contribution than an illiterate one. The best that can be said for stem cell research is that it is "promising." In New Jersey, the aim is to raise $300 million for a stem cell project. New Jersey is home to the city of Camden, one of the poorest and most crime-ridden cities in the country. It could make better use of that kind of money.

I can only offer some hypotheses. One of them is that when George W. Bush and his crowd, luddites and religious extremists to those on the left, did not like embryonic stem cell research, that automatically made it a major cause for liberals. Well, there is no doubt that, if Bush opposes something, that makes it tempting to embrace it. His common sense and good judgment are not excessively noticeable.

Another hypothesis is that many liberals have embraced the medicalization of everything in sight, advocate an endless war on death and disease, and support ever-increasing research budgets, far more enthusiastically than a few decades ago. In the 1960s and at least part of the 1970s, liberals tended to be in the vanguard of critical thinking about medical progress, willing to ask the hard questions and, if necessary, to hold up alleged progress. That was the role of Science for the People, the Union of Concerned Scientists, and of many of the scientists who brought about the moratorium on recombinant-DNA in the mid-1970s. That was considered the proper liberal stance.

By the 1990s, that movement had faded, its place to be taken by a fair number of bioethical cheerleaders for science, fast to shoot down objections to this or that line of research, and by an almost total disappearance from the scene of scientists willing to be troublesome. And many bioethicists found it hard to think of any good reasons why they should not be supported by the pharmaceutical industry or help them, for a modest fee, solve their ethical problems. Stem cell research has just the kind of enemies, deliciously awful, to make the cheerleading all the more virtuous. What could be in greater need of defense than the beleagured American research industry, down to its last $100 billion or so in expenditures each year, and maybe slipping from the 20 percent profit margin traditionally enjoyed by the drug companies? I suppose there are many ways of speaking truth to power that I have overlooked, but I doubt that technological boosterism is one of them.

My last hypothesis is the most self-evident. The California stem cell initiative had a super-rich real estate tycoon leading the charge, lots of money from the biotechnology industry, the support of celebrities, and that best of American mixes, the possibility of saving millions of lives while making millions of dollars. Illiterate adults, many of them illegal immigrants and other kinds of undesirables, have no industry support, spend little time in Beverly Hills with celebrities, have weak voting power, no money for organizing, and poor leadership. They were lucky the papers even noticed them. We may or may not ever see a payoff from stem cell research, but that's where the action is, and with the blessing of liberals. This is not a proud moment for us.

 

Readers respond

I enjoyed reading Dan Callahan's interesting discussion of the liberal fetish for embryonic stem cells. Dan finds literacy programs a more worthy social priority than merely "promising" but hugely expensive research into the medical applications of stem cells. I think Dan misses something else that can be said on behalf of this research. While those who emphasize the possible medical applications of embryonic stem cell research think of it as applied science, it can also be viewed as basic science. Every part of a human body is assembled from parts that were once stem cells. Determining the conditions required to turn stem cells into specific tissue types will tell us a lot about how humans are made - it may even tell us something about what it means to be human. We can compare the large sums of money spent on stem cell research with the huge sums consumed by space exploration, another necessarily expensive basic research program. It's certainly up for debate in a liberal society how much money gets spent on basic science - a society that sends space rockets to Saturn's moons when so many people can't even read may seem obscene. But speaking as someone employed as an academic philosopher (and financially independent of pharmaceutical or biotechnology companies), I rather like the idea of the pursuit of knowledge as one of society's priorities. Those who defend NASA's billions sometimes point to the practical second-hand benefits of space exploration - even going so far as to fraudulently claim Velcro and Tang for NASA. They should instead insist that space research is really about answering fundamental questions about the makeup of the Universe and our place in it. Perhaps we should say that embryonic stem cell research is really about finding out how human beings are made. It might just possibly lead to cures for terrible diseases too.

- Nicholas Agar

 

I'll start off by saying that I deeply respect Daniel Callahan's body of work, and that What Price Better Health should be mandatory reading for anyone concerned with contemporary problems in medicine. That being said, I think he paints with too broad a brush in his recent post "Liberals and their Ill-Liberal Policies," and thus misses some important social structural dynamics around Proposition 71, and human stem cell research in the United States generally. More importantly, Professor Callahan trades on a political distinction that is less than helpful for understanding the benefits and dangers of our current situation. Lets take a closer look at some of his hypotheses.

We'll call the first hypothesis the "Blue State Hypothesis;" namely, Prop 71 passed because Californians wanted to give the bird to the Bush Administration. This seems plausible at first blush, but historically Californian voters' record is much more uneven. For example in 1994, voters approved both Proposition 184 (three strikes initiative) and 187 (denial of basic social services to undocumented workers). In 1998, voters passed both Prop 227 (eliminated bi-lingual instruction in public schools), and Prop 4 (which banned steel-jaw leg hold traps used by fur trappers). In 2004, the same year Prop 71 passed, citizens voted down Prop 72, which would have expanded basic health care insurance coverage. Overall, this presents a confusing, if not schizophrenic, picture for a blue state. Clearly, voting outcomes do not map cleanly onto other variables, such as party affiliation or ideology, and certainly it is difficult from these outcomes to determine if the state has a single voting profile. The bottom line is that initiative voting patterns represent a complicated mix of factors that do not reduce to single issues, such as opposition to federal policies or people.

The second hypothesis ("The Liberal Bio-elite") is that liberals now unquestioningly support biomedical research. During the Proposition 71 campaign, however, the leading public critics of the initiative were not the Catholic Church or pro-life organizations. They were left-leaning public interest organizations, such as the Center for Genetics and Society (CGS) and the Feminist Pro-choice Alliance. CGS in particular were instrumental in raising a variety of issues, from open meetings to financial disclosures, both during the campaign and the early stage of implementation of the California Institute for Regenerative Medicine (CIRM). The Christian Right has been completely absent from any of the public meetings of the CIRM, and has placed all their bets on stopping the Institute through the court system, which appears to have been an unsuccessful gambit.

The final hypothesis ("Follow the Money") is somewhat muddled. Prop 71 was well on the way before Bob Klein (the "super-rich real estate tycoon" that Professor Callahan describes) was brought on board. The California legislature had already passed several stem cell-friendly pieces of legislation, led by Sen. Deborah Ortiz (D-Sacramento). In fact, Sen. Ortiz should be given the credit for coming up with the idea of using the initiative process to fund stem cell research on a state level. He also asserts that the initiative received "lots of money from the biotechnology industry." This claim is difficult to evaluate, since Professor Callahan does not specify how much money constitutes "lots." Biotech's response to Prop 71 was mixed. While the southern California biotech trade organization (Biocom) quickly endorsed Prop 71, the northern California trade org (BayBio) was somewhat ambivalent, and held off endorsement until the end stages of the campaign. The largest donors to the Yes on 71 war chest, including Klein himself, were wealthy individuals that did not have direct ties to biotech. Certainly these individuals possess mutual funds or hold stock in biotech companies that could potentially benefit from Prop 71's largesse. However, the potential payoffs from a stem cell therapeutic breakthrough are so distant and uncertain that belief in a short-term financial windfall from this sector is ludicrous. Indeed during the campaign and after, venture capital firms had mixed opinions about Prop 71 and stem cell research more generally. The history of biotech in California is a mixture of a few spectacular successes, and exponentially more dismal failures.

I will finish by saying that I am deeply sympathetic to Professor Callahan's concerns about the use of public revenues for biomedical science at the expense of other priorities. However, to frame this situation in terms of a liberal/conservative distinction misses some of the most interesting and vexing issues that human stem cell research, and biotechnology in general, are provoking. Human stem cell research in particular has fractured older political constellations, and has helped to forge novel alliances. One does not have to look far; in California, progressive pro-choice feminists are in dialogue with conservative pro-life activists over such issues as the dilemmas and inequities of egg donation for nuclear transfer experiments, experiments that will be a priority of CIRM funding. Thus, it is critical that we expand our political imaginations beyond binary categories to help us think about the complexities and dangers that suffuse through our biotechnological present.

- Chris Ganchoff
University of California, San Francisco

Posted by Joyce Griffin at 05/11/2006 12:00:00 AM | 


Comments
I discovered your blog site on google and check a few of your early posts. Continue to keep up the very good operate. I just additional up your RSS feed to my MSN News Reader. Seeking forward to reading more from you later on!…
Posted by: magyblog@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 8/16/2013 2:56 PM


thanks for sharing this article
Posted by: firecruch@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 3/12/2015 10:25 AM


thanks for his information
Posted by: ririncantik0@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 4/13/2015 4:04 PM


I hаvе beеn іn loоk fоr оf ѕоme information abоut іt аlmoѕt threе time. Yоu served mе а lot іndeed аnd analyzing thіs уour publish I hаve fоund mаnу nеw аnd uѕеful information abоut thiѕ topic.
unlock cell phones
http://cellunlockrs.net/
Posted by: lenovodell637@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 5/7/2015 6:50 AM


The Androgen commercial mentions some but omits other serious risks of testosterone replacement therapy. The risk of cardiovascular events, for instance, is not mentioned...anti aging fitness workout
Posted by: jamalasjhar34@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 5/10/2015 7:07 AM


first hypothesis the "Blue State Hypothesis;" namely, Prop 71 passed because Californians

jaipur to delhi taxi
http://jaipurdelhitaxi.com/
Posted by: aarijali100@gmail.com ( Email ) at 5/11/2015 2:05 AM


In the allergy medication ad, when they get to talking about how the drug may cause dry mouth, we could see the allergy-prone woman with the magical weeds growing inside her mouth....

here
Posted by: jamalasjhar34@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 5/11/2015 6:06 AM


I have express a few of the articles on your website now, and I really like your style of blogging. I added it to my favorite’s blog site list and will be checking back soon.
link building
Posted by: lenovodell637@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 5/12/2015 3:46 AM


Thіs site іs excellent аnd ѕо іѕ hоw the subject matter was explained. You're іn point оf fact а just rіght webmaster.


cloud based ticketing system
Posted by: jamalasjhar34@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 5/12/2015 6:43 AM


Fashion experienced persons world-wide monitor the modern bunch connected with fragrance start out there. In actuality fragrances perform large location.
Free Ebook Downloads
Posted by: jamalasjhar34@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 5/14/2015 6:08 AM


Thank you for the great article I did enjoyed reading it, I want to encourage that you continue your great job, have a good day.
www.continuedinnovation.com/best-wireless-earbuds/
Posted by: lenovodell637@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 5/17/2015 8:01 AM


Very interesting post I like your website keep up the great posts. bee problem in house
Posted by: lenovodell637@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 5/18/2015 8:23 AM


Explorer to easily distinguish between day and night, but also has a tough shell, which is true for the expedition challenge the limits.
teak lawn furniture
Posted by: lenovodell637@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 5/19/2015 7:43 AM


the iPLEDGE program is to ensure that female patients are committed

ants
Posted by: aarijali100@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 5/20/2015 6:43 AM


I rеallу enjoyed this article, іt was informative аnd helped open mу mind tо nеw possibilities. Thаt іs the power оf the internet, connecting people worlds аpart аnd allowing uѕ tо learn аnd grow together. Free Ebooks
Posted by: lenovodell637@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 5/20/2015 9:19 AM


Thank you for your beautiful articulation of the media's mess.
Hotels in Durban
Posted by: aarijali100@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 5/20/2015 9:21 AM


You have done a great job. I will definitely dig it and personally recommend to my friends additional reading
Posted by: ehtishamkhan0342@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 5/21/2015 6:33 AM


There is a lot of information here that can help any business get started with a successful social networking campaign!
the family law practice bristol
Posted by: lenovodell637@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 5/21/2015 9:21 AM


crime-ridden cities in the country. It could make better use of that kind of money http://www.internetcasinodir.com
Posted by: goodperson421@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 5/21/2015 12:08 PM


I like the part where you say you are doing this to give back but I would assume by all the comments that this is working for you as well.
unlock cell phone
Posted by: jamalasjhar34@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 5/25/2015 2:55 AM


There is a lot of information here that can help any business get started with a successful social networking campaign
viagra generika
Posted by: aarijali100@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 5/25/2015 3:57 AM


I hаve read аll the comments аnd suggestions posted bу the visitors fоr this article are vеrу good,We wіll wait fоr уour nеxt article so only.Thanks!
smart happy birthday wishes
Posted by: lenovodell637@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 5/25/2015 9:17 AM


I rеallу enjoyed this article, іt was informative аnd helped open mу mind tо nеw possibilities...

buy neopoints paypal
Posted by: jamalasjhar34@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 5/28/2015 7:55 AM


I hаve read аll the comments аnd suggestions posted bу the visitors fоr this article are vеrу good.
family room
Posted by: aarijali100@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 5/28/2015 8:01 AM


Your work is very good and appreciate you and hopping for some more informative posts.
web design cost
Posted by: lenovodell637@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 5/30/2015 3:20 AM


Being in the top positions of look for for a specific keyword or set of look for phrases that can assure you more clicks of the mouse, resulting in improved visitors research and rising sales chart.
more information
Posted by: lenovodell637@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 5/30/2015 8:20 AM


Is there anybody else getting the same RSS issues? Anyone that knows the answer will you kindly respond? Thanks!!

everglades national park in florida
Posted by: jamalasjhar34@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 6/1/2015 6:54 AM


Being in the top positions of look for for a specific keyword or set of look for phrases that can assure you more clicks of the mouse, resulting in improved visitors research and rising sales chart. tongkat ali reviews
Posted by: ehtishamkhan0342@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 6/8/2015 4:26 AM


Great article its very striking. You have beautifully presented your thought in this blog post.
miami to key west bus tour
Posted by: aarijali100@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 6/9/2015 5:25 AM


It’s always so sweet and also full of a lot of fun for me personally and my office colleagues to search your blog a minimum of thrice in a week to see the new guidance you have got. natural remedies for allergies
Posted by: ehtishamkhan0342@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 6/10/2015 1:56 AM


wish to suggest you few interesting things or advice. Perhaps you could write next articles referring to this article.
packers and movers in pune
Posted by: aarijali100@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 6/10/2015 7:17 AM


You are an exceptionally proficient blogger. I am certain they will understand numerous new things here than any other person!
brochure design
Posted by: lenovodell637@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 6/15/2015 8:50 AM


My family and here I got the complete details of the best resort in UK. I will soon get back to you people to know about the best packages that you offer. Thank you...

http://www.mypsychicadvice.com/
Posted by: jamalasjhar34@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 6/16/2015 3:20 AM


I will soon get back to you people to know about the best packages that you offer. Thank you.

seo-tag.gr
Posted by: jamalasjhar34@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 6/17/2015 3:26 AM


It help me very much to solve some problems. Its opportunity are so fantastic and working style so speedy.
Tinnitus Miracle Free Download
Posted by: lenovodell637@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 6/17/2015 7:52 AM


Great article its very striking. You have beautifully presented your thought in this blog post....

check here
Posted by: jamalasjhar34@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 6/18/2015 3:11 AM


The final hypothesis ("Follow the Money") is somewhat muddled. Prop 71 was well on the way before Bob
northern kentucky personal injury attorney
Posted by: aarijali100@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 6/20/2015 11:50 PM


I have been searching the Internet for fun and came upon your website. Fabulous post. Thanks a ton for sharing your knowledge! It is great to see that some people still put in an effort into managing their websites.
Dragon City Hack
Posted by: lenovodell637@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 6/21/2015 3:30 AM


I am always searching online for articles that can help me. There is obviously a lot to know about this. I think you made some good points in Features also. Keep working, great job..

how to get rid of bees in ground
Posted by: jamalasjhar34@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 6/22/2015 6:28 AM


I would add that interestingly, risk is pretty log distributed, as if we can only detect things being things being 10x as risky.

philadelphia real estate lawyer
Posted by: jamalasjhar34@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 6/23/2015 6:01 AM


I am always searching online for articles that can help me. There is obviously a lot to know about this. I think you made some good points in Features also. Keep working, great job.

auto detailing bellevue
Posted by: jamalasjhar34@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 6/25/2015 4:32 AM


Wow this is a great post. This contain have many useful information. Please post more information to share with us...
Twitter accounts
Posted by: lenovodell637@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 6/25/2015 4:39 AM


I give you quality USA Phone verified accounts with guarantee in very cheap price. I have been doing this for many years and joined here to expand my reach and further develop my career. Feel free to ask me any questions about my service.
facebook pva
Posted by: lenovodell637@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 6/28/2015 5:24 AM


nia won $3 billion in state bonds to initiate a stem cell research program, the media there was reporting that there are 2.5 million illiterate adults in that state. There is plenty of experience on successfully teaching adults to read, plenty of evidence that an adult illiterate has an almost hopeless economic future in this country, and plenty of evidence that a literate citizenry makes a
backlinks uniqeu domains
Posted by: robinjack10@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 6/29/2015 1:43 AM


I really liked the font you've chose to use in this article. Could I please get the name of that font? I wanted to use it in my project now. Thanks very much! social media accounts
Posted by: lenovodell637@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 6/29/2015 3:42 AM


Yes, great US Military force. Also, in his post you have given a chance to listen about US Military. I really appreciate your work. Thanks for sharing it.

click here
Posted by: jamalasjhar34@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 6/30/2015 3:47 AM


I hаvе beеn іn loоk fоr оf ѕоme information abоut іt аlmoѕt three time. Yоu served mе а lot іndeed аnd analyzing this уour publish I hаve fоund mаnу nеw аnd uѕеful information abоut this topic.
more hints
Posted by: lenovodell637@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 7/1/2015 6:14 AM


Thank you for the great article I did enjoyed reading it, I want to encourage that you continue your great job, have a good day
jaipur to delhi cab
Posted by: aarijali100@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 7/1/2015 8:11 AM


mypsychicadvice hindu religion Hinduism as a Religion: Life, Rituals, Gods, Beliefs, and Temples mypsychicadvice.com


http://www.mypsychicadvice.com/category/mypsychicadvice-hindu-religion.aspx
Posted by: jamalasjhar34@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 7/2/2015 2:48 AM


This is highly informatics, crisp and clear. I think that everything has been described in systematic manner so that reader could get maximum information and learn many things...

how do you refinance a car
Posted by: jamalasjhar34@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 7/2/2015 6:13 AM


I needed to much obliged in your time for this sublime read!! I decidedly getting a charge out of every tad bit of it and I have you bookmarked to look at new stuff you weblog post.
Manual blog comments
Posted by: lenovodell637@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 7/6/2015 4:54 AM


I think this post hits the nail on the head for at least one of the reasons why this is so and gives me another way of looking at the meaning behind them. Much love to you!

active instagram followers
Posted by: jamalasjhar34@gmail.com ( Email | Visit ) at 7/6/2015 5:55 AM